Yes, they are.
Which also makes me think that they don’t think Arete is the best lynch, and there is evidence that people are fine with at least either one being lynched.
It could, but we’re not
Can you explain why that is because that’s exactly the PoE of my top scumread at the moment
Well i think we just are seeing the game differently. Maybe it’s because i havent had a lot of time but the way i was reading diggity came off as scum, and marshals logic is compelling for an arete kill.
Also yes this logic makes zero sense
‘one person of unknown alignment agrees with them’ does not make someone town
it felt like you were accusing poss off of the fact that they sus arete but don’t think they are the best lynch. mb if that wasn’t what you were getting at.
does this post implies diggity v arete are tvt?
What specifically about Marshal’s logic did you find compelling
and what about Diggity came off as scum to you
Unknown alignment, yes. But that does not mean we can automatically assume scum.
If a legitimate cop outs and says that someone is guaranteed to be mafia, should you follow the cop but continue to scumhunt, or just ignore the cop and fail to lynch the redcheck?
I’m not automatically assuming scum
Even if Kyle is town I don’t get your logic for how that makes Possessed town
He plays like i do as scum
Something feels weird here. People are saying that they re-read PKR, but any scum can say that they re-read someone and came up with a different answer. See the last cop13 game Marshal was in.
What specifically do you see as being similar to your scum play? Can you quote specific posts?
Not right now as im in a restaraunt kitchen washing dishes