[SFM] Candlelight [The Beasts Achieve Victory]

Can you go back and look? I know the basically 2 day layoff will mess with your reads, but this is vital for me right now.

i doubt this world tho because kyle seems to already have some kinda info on one of the list people

ā€œoh neat Marshal claimed neutā€
ā€œwait but itā€™s Marshal this might be a reactiontestā€
ā€œeh but itā€™s pretty elaborate to be a reactiontestā€
ā€œPKR is being kind of wolfyā€
ā€œalso his claimed class makes no sense for a humanā€
ā€œand heā€™s trying to defend himself based on his claimed class even though that claim negatively confirms himā€
ā€œwow okay PKRā€™s just a wolfā€
ā€œletā€™s lynch PKRā€
ā€œPossessed is defending PKR, whoā€™s an obvious wolf, is this JoJo 2.0 or is Possessed his partner, letā€™s ask him some questions to find outā€

I think Marshal might be scum here.

btw his claim is semi confirmed by the op

1 Like

Second clause denotes that thereā€™s a killing power during no light
Because otherwise it would just be dumb

2 Likes

In any case Iā€™m not reading him off that
Was just commenting

The specific thing that made no sense was the thing where he was claiming a class that didnā€™t suicide if it killed a human, but did if it killed a Beast

one of the things Amiā€™s complained about with ToL!Fool is that it punishes for correct scumreads so I didnā€™t think at first that heā€™d put in a class that literally suicides based on killing a scum

No, you have to read them off of that or else youā€™re apparently scum.

Hmmmmm marshal hmmmmmmmmmmmmm

god PKRā€™s tone is so easy to scumread
I can definitely believe pushes on them

Iā€™m not really feeling W!Marshal

I donā€™t think W!Marshal would immediately hardclaim neut and not rescind, since doing so would make him basically a free lynch/free vig shot (first one doesnā€™t totally apply because of the passive heā€™s claiming, but second absolutely does)

No AtE is allowed in my thread

1 Like

No but seriously

Minimal fluff
Minimal AtE

1 Like

That was not AtE

That was a joke

fluffposting is punishable by severe dissapointment from me

and also has mech drawbacks(or a lack of benefits) with my role

Nvm

This is kind of why I feel pretty bad about your slot this game
This isnā€™t insightful.
It basically says ā€˜Marshal wouldnā€™t hardclaim neutral since that makes him easier to lynchā€™ when he claimed if he got lynched 25 hours would be removed from candle

My re-evaluation of Marshal during the pause has gave me the resolution that Marshal is only being half truthful on his claim. I believe the part that is a lie is the part on the wincon; it might not be as town-favored as we believe.

ā€¦I mean, I did in fact mention that in the postā€¦