[SFM] Evolution Mafia [Mafia wins]

Oh I guess this kind of implies I hadn’t already voted myself.

Meeh, I probably am not getting it, so the jig is up. I tried to force votes on me by announcing I had voted myself earlier. Let me think who would be good.

stop me here if it’s angleshooting
but if vengeful is a thing, and kat says scum vengeful is stupid and overpowered
then can we conclude that scum killer isn’t a thing?

he’s in his own category

/shrug

No.

no because scum could have a stupid and overpowered role

on the first evo point :eyes:

I’m still saying we could give it to Katze.

my magical gut read is telling me arete is town

but my brain is telling me arete is scum

arete says same

I’ve written reads like these as a wolf a lot. I don’t know if that really applies to you, though.

I’m never doing that either.

actually Italy I have a question

is it specifically ‘if you die under any circumstances you get a vengeful kill’ or is it some variant of ‘if you die to an attack you get a vengeful kill’

because the answer is the difference between ‘brokenly overpowered’ and ‘borderline useless’ for scum

i really need to play this game at a decent time that isn’t 3 in the goddamn morning so that i can actually ask myself “hey what do you think arete’s alignment is” and actually be able to read them

1 Like

You select a player each night. If you die, you will attack that person.

I know my commentary’s lackluster, but I honestly don’t know what to do here. If I go town leader mode, I’m just going to make things worse with my garbage reads.

Also, if Squid’s role is something underwhelming at evolution 1-2 and yet she fought so hard for an evolution point, it’s bad villagery play :<

i agree with a lot of aretes readlist which is a good sign but where me and them don’t see eye to eye is like my 2nd highest townread and one of my null reads

oh nvm this sounds kinda trash on scum

Like powerwise:

1-point invest
2-point killing
2-point protecting

Good killing might have most impact.
But… bad killing might have most negative impact.

2-point protective is way better than 1-point invest and can’t go wrong.

Tbh I see it as 2-point killing vs 2-point protective.

okay but like

does it apply to deaths to lynch

because that’s the thing that makes scum Vengeful roles overpowered

Night death specifically.

oh if it’s specifically night death then that’s not overpowered for scum at all