[SFM] Evolution Mafia [Mafia wins]

Forum Matches Completed
#8381

It’s conventional but it was worked out via mountainous that 4 scum in a 16er is still a 70% scum winrate or smthing ridiculous

#8382

4 mafia 1 LW, 1 Factional kill…maybe slightly unbalanced but I think the mechanics made up for it.

#8383

Only issue in this set-up was an informed LW.

1 Like
#8384

That’s with random lynching and if your town can’t do better than random chance at lynching scum they deserve to lose

Also this wasn’t Mountainous

#8385

Yeah its like 4 scum in a 22er mountainous thats balanced

#8386

No that was overtime in real games not random

#8387

i mean having italy shred through 3 town likely didn’t help

1 Like
#8388

This was mountainous with some mechanics that most people didn’t get to use

#8389

Yes

#8390

Pfft speak for yourself marshie

#8391

Didnt like 50%+ of the people evolve

#8392

all i did mechanically was roleblock ur lost wolf n1 so :man_shrugging:

1 Like
#8393

For mashes the rule is 20-25% scum but for effectively vfm like this its not fair to have 5/17 imo

#8394

imo when its not mountainous like this game was, i think it was fine. Maybe 4 would have been more balanced, but its a learning process

#8395

30% of the players were scum

This isn’t balanced even if it was a mash

#8396

Town had two kill classes, one that evolved into a Prince basically. It was 4 uninformed mafia to LW; if we didn’t pick up on Arete that could has been a misfire.

Is 5 starting scum in a 17 player fair? Not fully, but its not terrible either.

And that town player list literally had us crapping our pants. Most of you guys are good readers and obvious town when town players.

#8397

it was probably scum sided

italy helped :eyes:

#8398

It still took 3 mislynches to win it, and likely more if Italy didn’t take out Eevee and Marshal.

#8399

Which is not balanced at all

Fair number of mislynches is number of mafia + 1

1 Like
#8400

I mean it took 3 mislynches + 3 misvigs, games with town KP require fewer mislynches to win in most cases for obvious reasons

I don’t disagree that 12v5 is scumsided but on that metric it’s fairly close to balanced