[SFM] Insurgency: Treason in Jugdral — Fire Emblem: Genealogy of the Holy War and Thracia 776 FM Game Thread: Game Over (8/24) — FINALE: Bow Before Loptous — The Loptrian Empire Wins!

[Hippolytus]

If I scumread the ppl leading discussions I’d be doing more rn.

[Chloe]

This is a difficult question without giving things away

But yes, I can prove my alignment/ability

[Chloe]

more specifically ability

which in turn should clear me

[Alice]

Tomorrow are we or a trusted player going to 100% know your alignment?

As in a modpeek or your flip?

[eevee]

Like I can prove my ability, but it in no way proves my aligment for example.

Oh btw - fun fact - killing clame from Yidali was fake, who would expect.

Unless they meant ITA, then yes, I can ITA. Lmao.

[Chloe]

No modpeek - I already claimed not to be IC

However, it depends (?)

Fuck im trying to stay vague

Its either everyone knows
or one person knows

[eevee]

Meh, good enough for me.

[Alice]

@Chloe

or one person knows

Can it be a person of your choice? If it does, then it should be on a trusted player. I’m not going to name targets for obv reasons.

[Alice]

Off-topic, but if I get one more person who thinks they are confirmable because they’re a tracker then I’m gonna blow my lid, seriously.

[Chloe]

Not my choice

But unless i missed something, should be trusted

[eevee]

@Chloe

Off-topic, but if I get one more person who thinks they are confirmable because they’re a tracker then I’m gonna blow my lid, seriously.

Trusted vigilante for killing a townie :^)

[Alice]

So re-reading my PoE and yeah, cheese can die.

Entire ISO from him is just excuses and claiming that inactivity is NAI.

If you have time to post these excuses then frankly you have time to make snap-reads.

[Alice]

@eevee

Trusted vigilante for killing a townie :^)

Depends on the shot, tbh. I’ll factor the shot in my reads.

[Alice]

Still think EVO should be today’s lynch and Leaf should be nightvig’d, tbh.

[Chloe]

So im multitasking like a mofo right now, so i havent had a chance to properly analyze everything up to this point - but im going to post what i have now so we can discuss

also if i dont post now it might be longer than anyone would wanna read

[Chloe]

oh wait lemme finish my thought on this one part

[sulit]

hello eevee

[PokemonKidRyan]

I’ve made 2 full reads on everyone in detail.
I at least will read it and I’m sure if people have read my reads then you don’t need to worry about yours being long.

[Chloe]

Post ~2590

CRich's vote analysis

@CRichard564

I’ve been reading through the votes on Chloe’s trial. The fact that my town reads pardoned Chloe means that her pardoners spew village at this point.

@CRichard564

Yet Ici, Derps and Apprentice didn’t pardon Chloe. I’ll have to keep a watchful eye on those slots.

@CRichard564

At this point, I think whoever is null/scum read and didn’t pardon Chloe are the slots that should be focused on for scum hunting.

@CRichard564

Anyway as I’ve revised Chloe as a town read now, then any one who didn’t vote to pardon Chloe is someone I would put in my PoE.

@CRichard564

I think everyone who pardoned Chloe is more likely town than mafia.

@CRichard564 bro, i townread you. This is not me trying to attack you - but please stop relying on vote analysis so heavily. Especially in this scenario. Unless the player flips, you shouldn’t be assuming the alignment of everyone based on these votes. Another problem with this is that you’re only analyzing who voted, but not why, if this were a regular trial and someone were hammered, you wouldn’t just look at who did the voting but you would look at their reasoning as well.

In fact, the only person who should be analyzing the votes during my trial is me, as I’m the only person who knows with 100% certainty that I am town. But I’m not going to do that because it won’t give us any information. Everyone who was around should have, and did, pardon. Town pardoned, scum also probably pardoned - pardoning a GT when its the consensus decision isn’t AI.

If you really wanna do votecount analysis, copy the votecount from before when i was on GT, and look at it after I flip, whenever that is, but preflipping is bad and it will just cloud your judgement for futer reads/decisions.

---

Post ~2610

Ici/PKR interaction about GT

@Icibalus

pkr it was a very suboptimal trial

@Icibalus

i haven’t commented upon it but trialing chloe was pointless, especially since you all but outed that you did it

@PokemonKidRyan

It paid off.
Chloe turned her thinking around and we got to discuss stuff.
I didn’t want to have to use my ability but it was the best of a worst situation.

@Icibalus

you did not fucking have to use your ability

@Icibalus

you had no reason to because you were barely being pushed and 2/5ths of the village core think you’re lock village
there was no threat to your life

@Icibalus

all you’ve done is made yourself become claimviggable

@PokemonKidRyan

I had to do it.
You don’t get it.
I didn’t do it for my own f’ing benefit.

@Icibalus

if it was a compulsive ability targeting a consensus wolfread was just about the worst thing you could’ve done

@PokemonKidRyan

What? How so?
I thought it was a good idea.

@Icibalus

choose somebody in PoE but out of left field and the villagers have to think, and you get legitimate information. choose somebody who is consensus w but in a weird spot, and people will all mass pardon, as they did.

you should have waited and targeted somebody like EVO or Lefia, or really anybody who isn’t Chloe.

I don’t really know how to start talking about this conversation, because there are multiple things I wanna say, and I don’t want to write a wallpost. Basically, I agree with Ici here, and the fact that I agree with him is making me townread him more. I think that the GT on me wasn’t optimal, but I didn’t want to say anything, as I was under the spotlight, and wanted to defend myself rather than trying to shift the conversation/blame onto PKR. I don’t know if scum!Ici would have the confidence to call out PKR for this play, but I don’t think I’ve ever seen scum!Ici? So I don’t want to use this reasoning to affect my read on his slot.
I think PKR is townie for softing the use of GT a few times before it happening. It was anonymous, so he could’ve just used it on anyone, if he were scum, and we probably wouldn’t have known it was him. I don’t think scum would ask for GT targets, and GT someone who is in PoE, and a possible wagon-bomber. Also his reactions to Ici calling this play shit seem genuine, so thats a thing.

---

Post ~2600

Hippo being Hippo

@Hippolytus

Apart from Hippoyeetus do we have any confirmed town?

@Hippolytus

Theres 2600 posts imma just read tomorrow tbh.

@Hippolytus

If someone has a link to the spark notes summary of D1 thatd be great.

@Hippolytus

Scrolling through I liked crichard and vulgard.

Didnt like mode or derps.

@Hippolytus

Cant remember too much else.

I don’t know if I’ve played games with Hippo before (and if I have, I don’t think its good that I can’t remember them) - but the lack of care to read the thread at all, or provide reasoning behind reads and pushes kinda irks me. I’m going to go back and ISO some of their past games when I have time to, but I’m mostly putting this here to ask others what they normally acts like as town vs scum, and if this is in either or both of those metas.

---

im going to eat lunch then continue but i’ll be chillin here for a lil bit

theres not a ton of stuff in here i mostly just wanted opinions on Hippo before i continued on

[Alice]

@Chloe

I don’t know if I’ve played games with Hippo before (and if I have, I don’t think its good that I can’t remember them)

We really need an anon game, tbh. It’s like meta talk is included in like every other post on this site.