CRich, if Apprentice is scum so am I. Also, that’s a terrible idea Hippo.
I think this discussion is pointless.
If you are actually interested in my take
If I were to host a mash, everyone with additional shots would be informed right away that they have additional shots. Giving people additional shots in secret doesn’t really seem to have a point to begin with.
I actually think the setup we’re playing right now has the same philosophy. I mean, you were informed, and you did fire the shot. Nobody else who fired was informed and they weren’t able to fire. Except…
@CRichard564 One question, though. Do you have another ITA shot available?
Kyo is #1 scumread, has been the lowest and really hasn’t improved… at all. They also claimed that they cannot vote, waited and then claimed jailkeep which I really think was just so they don’t get sus’d.
Gorta is my #2 scumread. I dislike his attitude towards the game as a whole and it feels as if he’s trying to be hedgy since iirc a lot of his posts were “(x) might be (y) but (z)”. The but being very fence-sitty.
SDA is fairly scummy to me, so I’d put him as #3. Only reason SDA is #3 instead of #2 is because I think that derps had some genuine reactions but they’re too few and far between.
If I put a 4th it’d be Hippo. Hippo’s attitude at multiple parts this game really doesn’t come from a pro-town perspective and I think even Hippo can attest to that.
1 Like
I’m thinking that Apprentice is capable of voting up his own group scum if he is starting scum for town credibility. Anything is possible here.
Derps hasn’t been helping the town all that much with analysis. I’m not 100% certain that there isn’t a world that he does this as town, yet I don’t like how little help he has been so far.
yeah i agree, in retrospect it was bad. i townread him loads till ppl started piling on him and i just jumped on the wagon and believed it and told ppl to shoot him lol. And then ici fucked off anyway.
but like
having an auction isnt even ai its such a dumb thing to go all in on a lie on lol.
i do wanna see eevee flip tomorrow in ita session but theres no way eevees flip outs the other two as scum - they must have realized eevee wld die v soon lol.
Can i just say: the chance there are 2 neutrals both with coin related mechanics is possible.
BUT i think the chance of 2 neutrals both with coin related mechanics AND both with true neutral wincons (ie not antitown) is super duper slim imo. Even if Eevee is neutral I’d be v surprised if they were anything but anti-town, cuz otherwise it wld be almost identical to the other role in both wincon and mechs.
1 Like
If Gorta gets lynched Today, that’d leave me with Derps… alright, I’ll investigate him at Night Phase.
Btw PKR, I disagree with your read on Kyo. Regardless of their behavior, they claimed Jailkeeper to negate Marshal’s redcheck on Centuries. I do not believe scum!Kyo would’ve done that; not even if Kyo/Marshal are W/W.
My biggest problem with Eevee is I can see him doing shenanigans as anything.
Eevee was the one who said about selling a frame and therefore intentionally sus’ing their slot so that they can rely upon it in defense if Eevee is scum.
Talk about Kyo's claim
This is basically Kyo’s fullclaim. Does it come from scum? Town Double ITA Event Shooting Treestump Jailkeeper. He didn’t claim if the jailkeep is day or night (I think it’s night, because it would be a form of angel if used during the day), but I think he claimed pretty much everything else.
I think this is a really weird claim, and it also seems super high-powered, but maybe it’s just a super strong role? Being essentially ITA immune and having a bonus ITA is pretty good on its own, but he’s also a JK.
Not sure if scum risks claiming treestump? Maybe I’m misreading it, but I really think that’s the claim. He said that “mafia never has this role” and “he is ita immune.” That’s basically Treestump fmpov.
If there are deepwolves in towncore, who do you think they are? I do think Ici has higher wolf equity after what he pulled on Centuries.
Second JK. And that CC like always comes from town imo. esp cuz kyo is mafia aswell lol. I don’t rlly wanna hang vader or gorta tbh.