how is this shading?
1 Like
At this point Seth you’re pushing me off of terminology and not actually what I’ve done; which was point out that I’m leaning towards them being wolves trying to look productive.
Justify why that post is scummy rather than using terminology for me please
Soolit said they Town read me but you don’t ask them about it but they answer you about it despite you not asking them. Bad.
/Vote ModeShifter
not the biggest fan of seths reasoning here
they say that kyo is shading when he’s clearly not
if what people said was right he could be wolfing as well
@GreenCatKid If you have time read my ISO on this game
https://forum.imperium42.com/t/short-fuse-v-day-1-6-12-mafia-win-day-1/81350/
It essentially has my entire argument why making desicive early reads isn’t scummy
I cba waiting for replies to copy/paste anymore
1 Like
I feel like my main concern is the lack of mention of me from Kyo.
What’s your read on me exactly Kyo?
You were null which is why I didn’t care about opinions on you. If I ever came to scumread you that’s when I would be concerned and if I came to townread you I would be concerned about who scumread you.
Vote Count
| Accused | Voters | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| clonedcheese | Ami, ModeShifter, Hippoyeetus | 3/9 |
| Italy | soolit, KyoDaz | 2/9 |
| DannyThyGamer | Wazza | 1/9 |
| ModeShifter | GreenCatKid | 1/9 |
| oB_L1ght | clonedcheese | 1/9 |
| Not Voting | Italy, PoisonedSquid, Alice, oB_L1ght, EVO, DannyThyGamer, TrustworthyLiberal, PokemonKidRyan, Crimson97 |
Wallpost lol
This wasn’t really a rolefish, more of a clarification
Let’s just say I have trauma from anime
weird vote out of nowhere
I hope people talk about this later on
I guess this is sulit’s new style?
Trying to read people early on - I’d say it still feels a little hasty, but seems fine
Down the scumlist you go
I get the not w/w part - don’t really see “both town” part
Frankly, I’ve probably done more mech talk than PKR. Why do you have me as a townread and PKR as a scumread?
If Italy’s meta is to not do anything as either alignment, how do you come to the conclusion that Italy is town?
Well you’re gonna find out
I think people do that as both alignments, especially day 1
I feel like this usually comes from town.
What scum would soft their claim this early on, this hard?
no
what’s a gladiator
you can confirm your role
what prevents a scum gladiator from claiming to gain towncred
Would someone else like to confirm this
ask and you shall receive
Question
do you see scum explicitly stating this D1
why?
Don’t think this would be considered “activity”
This is NAI - if anyone has a shot, please don’t shoot before lots of deliberation
200 posts in is not the time to do so.
To be fair there were not many meaningful content by then
again this is not shade
why do people think shading = doubting?
shading is suspecting that someone might be scum
different from just saying that their opinion is wrong
Correct use of shade
I am, or was, suspicious of sulit for seemingly jumping to leans pretty early on
At this point I think it’s just their “new playstyle”
well guess what
My scum meta (and also my town meta) so far on this site has been being lazy
I kinda want to become a better player that people like and look up to in the future
so again this is NAI
I agree with Italy on this; I will be taking note of any unusual behavior during this time, but I don’t see benefit in trying to actively scumhunt D1.
Didn’t see this at the time
again I am collecting opinions here to note everyone’s POV - you will see no active pushes from me D1, probably ever under normal circumstances
can we stop with the name puns
As previously noted, there’s a difference between shading - calling them potential scum - and just calling them unnatural/bad play
TL;DR:
- people need to learn what shading is
- you won’t get a readlist from me d1 other than weak townleans and weak scumleans
1 Like
ill read up on italy since this thread needs more activity
i don’t know italy’s meta but i think he’s ether a lying wolf or used his “claim” to escape being lynched
nether of these are how you should be playing this game 
but i don’t wanna lynch him yet because for some reason i think he might be telling the truth
so he’s a null/questionable for me
1 Like
Italia has been more active in this game that in Hydra 9JK, which points more to a villager for them. My two main sus at this point are Soolit and cheese. Soolit I’ve already stated a few times the reasons why (trying to justify playing differently, trying to get pocketed, etc.), however with cheese I’ve just been reading up on other people’s posts and agree with what has been brought up. For my town leans I have KyoDaz and GCK. Kyo has been active in the thread and has been making asking for actual reasoning behind things. Doing this as scum would be absolutely illogical because if the person you were pushing actually has good reasoning, that would both help tr the other person, and also push suspicion onto you, which is personally something I think Kyo would know better than. GCK is really just a gut, though. They seem to be trying their best, although they aren’t contributing too much they are still trying to give their reads even if they can’t really follow up on them.
1 Like