[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

Forum Matches
#2003

I still think gorta discarding Tracker is whack when the only things better are like Watcher and Bloodhound. I also think socially that gorta takes a lot of pride in his scum game and wants to prove what he can do and would just pick scum if given the option to. Is that kind of a shitty reason to push someone? Yeah. But I think it’s true regardless.

Uh I remember liking Light’s posts in general but his reasons for sussing me/Eli felt really off. I mean my last ~5 town games I’ve barely posted due to crippling WiM so him scumreading me for hardly posting is whacko.

Surge, cloned, Wiisp probably all town

I like Ami’s tone although not much content but I still think >rand V

GGhana is whack so I’m not sure how to really read them, but I think their posting has gotten better over time and their activeness to get thread moving in a solving direction makes me feel comfortable townleaning them

#2004

I found it cringe that he hasn’t been active, but I read everything from light and he just seems like light. He’s basically got this mix of fluff mech and just normal solving. I’m gonna compare him rn to one of his scum games later, because I feel null on this right now.

As much as I don’t like how he’s been talking to me this game, AT is probably town. The way he plays is really similar to Deus Ex 4, the last game he was town. He’s just heavily pushing on someone D1 (Ghana) like he literally did to me in the last game on D1.

#2005

I don’t have an opinion on this and I don’t want this to be a huge topic, but I think there is more then just those two.

#2006

Now this is what I want to see, I think this thread is kinda going down the toilet because it’s just become 6 people yelling at each other, we need fresh ideas

#2007

On this i mean gorta mostly*

#2008

I was looking specifically at investigatives I’m sure you could make an argument for something else. Tbh more of my reasoning on gorta is I literally just think the guy would pick scum if he rolled it at all.

#2009

@TrustworthyLiberal @eevee @Soulshade55r @Arctic
Give me 3 scum reads please, you’re probably the people I think are most scummy so yeah.

#2010

Ohh, alright that makes sense, thanks for clarifying. I’ll look more into gorta when i do the same to light later on. Also, I’m not sure how to back evidence behind this

Does gorta seem more bored/slanky as town?

#2011

alright I’m going to bed now good luck guys

Town
Light, Whysper, Surge

Probably town

Wiisp

Nulltown

Min, Crichard

Null - all them fluffposters

Nullscum

Gorta, Amelia

Probably Scum

Eevee, Soulshade, Trustworthy Liberal

:joy_cat: LOCK :joy_cat: SCUM :joy_cat:

ArcticXI

sheep my reads thanks

  • town god ghana
1 Like
#2012

I don’t think so

I want to compare this eevee game to Deus Ex

Among us with friends called

#2013

explain why Amelia is null scum? Amelia usually has a volume tell

#2014

Didn’t I already do this before?

Lets copy the generic formular of

Ping someone

HaY dAY 1 buT dO u hAf ScuM weadS?

Let people develop naturally stop asking people for reads you’re boring me to death wolfy

#2015

because all the fluff and little content, she’s one of the highest posters and has basically done nothing

#2016

hmmm looks like someone’s trying to find an excuse for not having reads

#2017

Zzzz
I’m scum guys
Zzzz
Can’t wait to be the d2 lynch because no one can do independent thinking

#2018

I gave reads before

#2019

bet you wish there was a day 1 yeet so you could self vote, would really add to the ate

#2020

You’re literally the one who pinged me

#2021

Please post them again, I don’t want to go dumpster diving for your reads. Plus are you seriously saying your reads haven’t changed at all?

#2022

Nah you can dive m8.

Stop pretending you care about the game state when you don’t