[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

Is different in concept of its own.
IE Getting rid of Miller is townyier then Tracker not to much but still.

Haha, calling Surge a bubblehead? I got a laugh out of this. :smiley:

Not as much difference while they are yes both town.

Oh heck I’ll say it now.
That I think the discarded cards from 1st rand shouldn’t have been mod revealed until end of game.
All it did this game was lead to people conf biasing their reads and that led to arguments.

My thoughts on the system.

Discard (3rd) be anti town: IE mine was survivor others had Mafia Goon and such.
Alignment: (Pre Town) Basic role VT or such ideally
Role: Best power of the three that kept it useful (IE to me Mason was by far best option)

There’s a reason why I’m not really reading based off of that

If that makes sense

I am just disappointed with this rand. Last time I had alien 1 shot recruiter, which is obviously much cooler than these roles

As I said before, even better would have been not to reveal the discards at all until end of game.

2 Likes

People are going to be miscleared because they left out a scum role when there could be more

I agree i shouldn’t have mentioned it will keep what i said as such and leave rest for post.

^^^
Best way to play with it honestly why i’ve been mostly out of the game

Last rand I rolled two ww roles and a Judas lol

Hell

Honestly a thought incase a setup like this ever ran again to have this disallowed kinda thing

I know this will be the case. In my first rand I had 2 alien roles and 1 cult role, so by this standard I would have been “clear”

Wonders why it got reranded with to little towns :thinking:

(See if we had a D1 yeet we could have atleast tested Gortus claim atleast)

Oh if anyone is going to ask if I’ll play a similar setup.
Uh yeah no just no.

I think i would with moderation.
IE not true random if that makes sense roll rand give people different options while not over tunning anything

I like the formula. It allows for fun and broken roles that aren’t common in most setups

Well this D1 put me off this sort of setup probably forever in case you haven’t noticed.