[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

[osieorb18]

@ChopChop

@osieorb18

Details? Examples? Throwing out buzzwords doesn’t quite cut it for me.

Doesn’t matter anyway, because your scum.

Either you are willing to work with people in the thread or you’re full of it.

[GGhana]

I mean I dont get why Ami’s claim cant just come from a scum who was caught doing the night kill

[ChopChop]

@osieorb18

There’s a very high chance that there’s ≥1 mafia in this group.

Whysper
Tsumugi
Cloned
Ami

Out of the four of those, I still don’t understand townreads on Whysper, but let’s say I give them the benefit of the doubt given the number of strong town meta reads on them.

Cloned is low activity and I’m down to eliminate there, but they’re less explicitly scummy than Tsumugi.

Ami’s claim is clearly true, though it doesn’t townfirm them. It does make them look a hell of a lot better than any of the others, not that it was difficult.

Out of these four, Cloned and Tsumugi have been extremely disengaged. For Cloned, they legitimately look to potentially be confused.

Tsumugi oozes infinite scumminess.

/vote Tsumugi

@Mercenary

Don’t think this makes Cloned look good after you flip.

[Trochilidae]

ok can we talk bout how none of these PR claims have been dying tho??
myself included before yesterday tbh

just
w h y are none of them dead

1. protectives/fear of protectives on them?
2. all of our reads are shit
3. some of them are scum

no clue which of em it is but i want this discussion

[ChopChop]

@GGhana

I mean I dont get why Ami’s claim cant just come from a scum who was caught doing the night kill

Possible. But then explain the Wiisp kill.

[osieorb18]

@ChopChop

@osieorb18

There’s a very high chance that there’s ≥1 mafia in this group.

Whysper
Tsumugi
Cloned
Ami

Out of the four of those, I still don’t understand townreads on Whysper, but let’s say I give them the benefit of the doubt given the number of strong town meta reads on them.

Cloned is low activity and I’m down to eliminate there, but they’re less explicitly scummy than Tsumugi.

Ami’s claim is clearly true, though it doesn’t townfirm them. It does make them look a hell of a lot better than any of the others, not that it was difficult.

Out of these four, Cloned and Tsumugi have been extremely disengaged. For Cloned, they legitimately look to potentially be confused.

Tsumugi oozes infinite scumminess.

/vote Tsumugi

@Mercenary

Don’t think this makes Cloned look good after you flip.

Yeah, except I don’t give a shit how Cloned looks. Because either they’re non-town, in which case I hope for them to be eliminated, or they’re disengaged town, in which case they are likely to continue to not be particularly helpful.

[GGhana]

read lights logs lmao

[osieorb18]

@Trochilidae

ok can we talk bout how none of these PR claims have been dying tho??
myself included before yesterday tbh

just
w h y are none of them dead

1. protectives/fear of protectives on them?
2. all of our reads are shit
3. some of them are scum

no clue which of em it is but i want this discussion

One or more of the seers is likely scum, most likely Chad.

[osieorb18]

@GGhana - Since Seth is useless (as usual), could you give me a few details towards your townread on Whysper when you get a sec?

[Trochilidae]

and eevee? how tf is eevee still alive

eevee with gun should be absolutely terrifying for scum imo considering it’s eevee and he’s already shot one scum

i’m not saying eevees lockscum or anything but i just am confused

[GGhana]

1: Easy to read later
2: Their reads all organic, and explore new territory instead of circiling well
3: They’re acting pretty similar to Deus Ex (where they were town)

[Trochilidae]

aight time for me to earn my keep and make dinner for the family

moar discussion
good
peace out

[osieorb18]

@GGhana

1: Easy to read later
2: Their reads all organic, and explore new territory instead of circiling well
3: They’re acting pretty similar to Deus Ex (where they were town)

Okay. I had the impression that they weren’t contributing much in terms of reads.

[osieorb18]

@Trochilidae

and eevee? how tf is eevee still alive

eevee with gun should be absolutely terrifying for scum imo considering it’s eevee and he’s already shot one scum

i’m not saying eevees lockscum or anything but i just am confused

I’m at a solve of 3-4 non-town in this pile of people:

Eevee (Nacho Tumbleweed) - Vigilante (Unconfirmed)
an_Gorta_pratai (Alma Armas) - 1-shot Prince (Unconfirmed)
TrustyworthyL (Kira Miki) - Red Check on Apprentice, Osie (Unconfirmed)
Surge (Gilligan) - Nurse (Unconfirmed)
Tsumugi-Shirogane (Sei P. Asagiri) - Seer, Not-Werewolf on Wisp, Werewolf on Osie (Unconfirmed)
clonedcheese (DDD)

[osieorb18]

That is, unless Trochi+Apprentice is a faction. (e.g. Cult)

But I don’t really want to think about that until after that list of 6 is sorted.

[osieorb18]

Or if there’s a deepwolf in my townreads, but that’s less likely at the moment.

[osieorb18]

For post-game cred:

Eevee+Gorta+Tsumugi non-Town

[Tsumugi-Shirogane]

Well tl apparently flaked on his claim, I assumed he was some normal alignment cop but then he claimed seer.

Which I dont know why he didnt just counter claim me if that was the case.

[GGhana]

yknow now that i think about it

@eevee

Why didnt you shoot anyone last night?

[TrustworthyLiberal]

Cause the same role is possible in this setup ergo no counter claims really.