[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

This is stilll where am at I think Ami has a much higher scum equality then Tsmugi right now.

I think Mechanically, ami is more likely scum than Tsumugi

while socially I think it’s more likely Tsumugi

so i dont really care which one we yeet tbh

I agree.

Or we can start working on gorta.
I still dislike that he took lynch immune rown over tracker.

Thats so negative utility tbh.

Im against lynching role whuch can potentially bring us something, while other 2 targets cannot

It’s just an order thing, but i believe that’s the worst choice out of all PoE to go first.

Yeah I know eventually we have to widdle that down.
But I feel today’s not the day we hit that. Since we have other options and all. Could force a third faction to shoot or lose or catch him in a lie. (tracked to somewhere cause rest of faction is dead)

Like in Gortu town world’s we lose two days having to kill him.

i mean considering he proposed that solution (wow what a townie thing to do, propose town waste 2 days on you wow locktown gorta is) I don’t think he’d mind

That’s why I said lynchproof is negative utility on gorta.

Like, he knwos he is lynch bait, so why wanting to waste 2 town days?
On the other hand - lynchproof scum would be strong.

That’s why I hate it.

Blocking lynches is never good for town.

And is never better than tracker.
Regardless what gorta says, this pick is awful.

Not only not providing information as tracker would, but also wasting town’s resources on solving him.

Apprentice (Deal) Werewolf Mason
Eli (Streaming-Chan) Werewolf Cop
Min (Dorothy) Mafia Goon
Cloned (DDD) One-shot Cult Recruiter
Ghana (Mario) Mafia Strongman
Wiisp (Stella Hoshii) Judas Vanilla
Amelia (Rad Shiba) Town FBI Agent
CRich (Virgilio) Town Mason

Fun fact, those are people we know/consider as town.

6 scum discards.
2 town discards.

ATN (Lexi Rivers) Town backup doctor
Soulshade5rr (Art von Delay) Vanilla Townie
Light (Anna Grahem) Town Vanilla

Those are dead scum.

0 scum discards
3 town discards

Ami (Dana Zane) Mafia Goon
Tsumugi-Shirogane (Sei P. Asagiri) Town Vanilla
an_Gorta_pratai (Alma Armas) Town Tracker
TrustyworthyL (Kira Miki) One-shot Townie Vanilla
ArcticXI (Beatrice Albert) Town Evangelistic

This is PoE

1 scum discards
4 town discards


I might be missing something, since OP is not updated and I did it from memory.
It’s just funny how these proportions work tho.

TBF my discard is a survivor but yeah

/shrug

I mean, yeah, now that you mention it, this was this role which became survivor after n1, right?

Confusing, considering it has townie in it’s name.

Yeah kinda werid name but it is what it is

Not a bad role tbh.

If you die early, you still has chance to win, where pure survivor would lose.

I almost took it honestly just thought cop might be better (And supersaint isn’t good for town really)

TL, one shot Werewolf would be best pick.

You are werewolf, but if you survive past night 1, you become survivor and can out your previous team :^)

I would have 100% done this IF i had a scum role to pick

Okay, serious question, where do we swap our vote?

I can’t read jokes online

because even if I claimed tracker “but you could be mafia”

I don’t want to get lynched as the optimal play, but if people did vote me I wouldn’t care. I would rather vote scum out, but if I get lynched I won’t mind too much

I have already said it’s better to get a scum out, but people will eventually try to lynch me and I won’t fight it too much