[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

And another time Surge provides random argument, gets provne he was wrong and disappears.

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAArgh.

Day 5 Votecount

Majority is 5.

Voted Count Accusers
Ami 1/5 Min
Eevee 1/5 Surge

Did you know? Host is getting anxious when she tries to do her homework!

I hope ur doin alright host ^^

min, give me one reason to think you are town.

Cause so far I saw you jumping around on random wagons, without analyzing if information on them is true.

Which looks like you don’t really care who is lynched, as long as it’s not you.

I believe you spewed out alien godfather becouse you are alien.
Either that or was really unlucky with your guess.

That was left for later analysis, but so far you are jumping with votes randomly, not analyzing.
That’s my point.

Surge pushes random bullshit, you jump and follow it.
I say something about night kills indicating that gorta is scum, you jump and follow it.
Gorta claims scum and offers to do one more kill, you jump and switch to ami.

How am I supposed to see it as townie?

You don’t have a stable vision, just jump whatever seems to suit you at current moment.

Because I picked town doctor as my role and alignment. :joy_cat:

This is wrong. I don’t want seth, whys, app, or myself hung as they are who I believe is town.

I am not switching votes as you’re falsely claiming I am. I literally scumread the people who you are claiming I am switching upon. It’s a matter of who I must believe have a higher chance of flipping wolf.

Again, the last part is false, also, i simply was meming and guessed souls alignment which is not impossible at all and we both know that.

I highly townread surge. I’m inclined to believe some of what he says. I don’t agree with him that you are lockscum.

That second part is a lie. I was planning on voting gorta today and I’ve scumread and voted him the entire game. Come on, at least try to not obviously lie about my intentions while voting.

Gorta/Ami are both scum. I literally am more inclined to keep someone alive who physically cannot win here and that they are working with me compared to someone who will not work with me. I also literally have confirmed heals which is a LOL, so you claiming there’s a possibility I don’t while looking at how messed up the nightkills have been is really funny.

You acused me of lying 3 times in that post.

Here you said I’m lying because you are not switching votes, and a moment later justifying why you was switching votes.

Here you say that you did analysis of anyone who you voted.

Sure, this one I can retreat if you give me quotes of analysis on me, Ami and gorta BEFORE you voted on this people.

Here you say that I was lying, because you do have a stable vision and planned on voting gorta again.
To add to that - you said before you wanted to vote person who has higher chance of flipping scum, yet you switched vote off gorta after they claimed scum.


I know that at the end of the post you explain why you switched your vote.

Nonethless your posts tries to say me that I’m lying, because I apparently knew what you were thinking, without you explaining it before.

See the problem?

@Apprentice

Are you gonna take over the leadership?

Yes gorta claimed scum but gorta is also by himself and is working with town.

Here’s a quote I found while scrolling through my iso literally from 10 days ago I know there’s earlier but my iso is a pain in the ass to look through

More of me from slightly more recent but not from today

Look more

I could find more quotes but I’ve literally scum read gorta this entire game

these are from weeks ago. I’ve kept the scumread on him since then. I’ve wanted to kill him for a while.

3 days ago just to be more recent.

I’ve kept him

On the back of my mind

This entire game.

From over a week ago*

Also @min

Truth is that scum needs you to die regardless of aligment.

And you can’t really argue with this.

Keeping doc alive when there is less and less targets (meaning more probability to hit heals and bigger chance to waste own kill) is… bad.

And if you slipped and not just luckilly guessed both aligment and role of a player, this also means you have to die. Possibly even more than because being doc.

Sorry if that bothers you or you think it’s anti-townie.
But like… considering only kill target who is not really confirmed is Apprentice and apparent doc is alive… there is really no much other choice.

You are lying because you’re implying I have no actual motivation between switching votes and I do and I’ve had progression obviously I was too quick to sheep seth but I haven’t done it recently

No it isn’t

It literally is against your Wincon to want to kill the doctor

I don’t care what you say

Unless you are scum, unless you’re playing some big brain move I literally don’t enjoy the way you’re acting

Obviously scum wants to kill the doctor

But you flashing a red sign saying kill min I literally just feel like you hate me which

Makes me not want to play

How?

How do you know he is by himself.
I mean, I believe it as well. But I’m not 100% trusting that.

And how is he meant to work with town?
He can’t kill me. And most likely he knows it, considering how much he was jumping on any argument Surge made about me.

He was trying to get rid of me during the day, not during the night after all.

If you vote out Ami rn, if he attacks me, nothing changes.
But if he attacked me before and knows he can’t kill me, he just won’t attack me again?

???

You just said you believed it as well I’m not sure why you’re questioning me on it

I believe him because he honestly has screamed by himself like the entire game

Edit: screamed as in he looked like he was by himself

Rather opposite, I’m implying that you have motivation which you are not really expressing.

Which makes it seem like you follow whatever lynch you are most content with right now, instead of creating one consistent vision of the world.

Like if you switch votes depending on a single post of other person (and tbh all 3 votes I mentioned before were becouse of someone’s else one post), it looks like you are either very unsure of own vision or just search for easy pushes.

My post on gorta could be me pushing agenda.
Surge’s post about me could be false. (And actually was)
gorta’s post about attacking me… was mostly theirs self-preservation.

Do you not trust your own vision enough to just follow others whole game?

I didn’t vote gorta because of you! I voted gorta because I’ve scumread him the entire game

If someone says they’ll work with me I’m prone to trust them and that’s what I’m doing with gorta

I think Ami is mafia ever since she was tracked to light therefore I’m voting her next