[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

Forum Matches
#2363
Ami

I remember one game Ami told me her meta and from what I can tell this screams town Ami. This will be disappointing, but Ami is just plain town. Ami isn’t try hard enough to be scum here in my opinion

Wiisp

This could be a playstyle thing, but Wiisp gives me weird vibes. Like they are a townlean to me, but I can’t help and feel there is something more going on with Wiisp. Like they make an effort to solve, ask decent questions and such, but something feels off. I still think this is a townlean, but I want to keep a watch on this slot.

CRich

In my opinion CRich reminds me of how he was in Deus Ex 4. I don’t know how to explain it, but his posting feels forced or strained. It’s not natural in my opinion. CRich has gotten better as scum, but still comes off as slightly forced. This is subject to change, but right now I am leaning towards CRich being scum.

Soul

I was slightly misunderstanding on eevee’s claims that Soul was deflecting questions. It seems they were speaking against using mech to call people town or scum, but on to the main thing. There isn’t much that I would call towny here. I want to put this as a null read for now because they haven’t shown themsleves to be “lock town” or even super towny. They are semi solvey and did answer any questions I asked, but I also see statments that reek of throwing shade “if I die lynch X or Y” and that kind of crap. I would say that I would lynch soul if there was a d1 because at some level I go scum read them by gut, but objectively I have to give this a null. I feel the arguments and attacks spoiled our tastes and I am willing to give Soul a second chance.

#2364

Tell me why that wouldn’t be the best game outcome for everybody if you don’t mind.

#2365

At least you seem more reasonable than others I could name.

#2366

Day 1 ends in 2 hours and 18 minutes.

1 Like
#2367

It took a bit, but I made some reads. I just feel like my reads are tainted by the shit that took place today and that I could do better with a clean slate on some people

#2368

i thought it was 1 hour and 12 minutes?

at least that’s what it says for me

#2369

My clock is off-sync with the forum’s, so the minutes are a little off though the hour is accurate.

#2370

I am really not satisfied with my read on Soul. There isn’t much more I can do though when their ISO is primarily just going at it with eevee and some mixed content. I’ll try to review some of Soul’s town games overnight

#2371

If this is going to be dead, then I am going to eat breakfast and ignore this

#2372

I can’t say I’m looking forward to D2 if this D1 is anything to go by.
Still that doesn’t mean I won’t try to solve this game, even though my odds of survival D2 aren’t the best.

#2373

This whole “I claim miller D1” thing is dumb.

It brings towncred, but at what cost if you’re town. However, the picking looked like there was no way to be wolf especially with a discarded judas card

I’m gonna purpose the following two scenarios:

  1. If Wiisp is town, their claimed role is fake and they actually have a stronger role.

  2. If Wiisp is wolf, they lied about having town psychiatrist and misjudged it’s power.

Currently leaning the second scenario.

#2374

Morning

#2375

Looks like marshal was just as selfish as me in terms of the role they chose

#2376

marshal? I mean Gorta, also probably still a wolf, that read list was also pretty mediocre
don’t care much for his prince claim and neither should u

#2377

if soul is a wolf, then ghana is like 99.9% of the time with him, I think?
probably

anyways I have very little time, off to work

#2378

Day ends in 24 minutes.

#2379

I thought this day ended later, than expected.

Panic

image

#2380

Wait, nevermind, there is no reason to panic.

If a vigilante exists just shoot into people who believe wiisp is randomly lieing.

If cops exist, someone should check wiisp.

If a watcher exist, please do check where you think is best.

image

#2381

Check gghana if u wanna be spicy and remove the idea of a power wolfee since he fits that bill

Or in soul, Arctic, Gorta, Tsumugi, Ami

U can shoot in any of those outside tsu, Ghana, Gorta

Light, and min are also good options

See most of y’all in day 2 if I don’t die to a loose cannon big or or an evil

#2382

I wouldn’t shoot light though, u can investigate him though

Do not touch surge, or TL

I need more time with No Name