[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

So? Doesn’t change the fact it’s unlikely

That’s a fallacious argument and you know it.

Turns out Cult doesn’t have factional convert.
Nice.

/vote TL

Prince is crinj

Those are not answering anything.
Don’t doge the question by asking own question to begin with.

And even if we consider it, it’s not a good reason, cause if someone is not very townie, you would be considering them in “null” state.
Yet you are actively creating scenarios ( Me + Tsumugi / GGhana / Wisp / Osie / Soul) and searching for slips.

You are convinced I’m scum.

So for the third time - what is your actual case on me being scum?
No, not null. Scum.

That’s also fake or at least very narrow part of the story.

You were searching scenarios and slips BEFORE today. (starting day 2, and today is day 4)
And you could only know about me faking a role today… right?

@GGhana

You are falling in Surge’s trap in his theories.

Ask him for general reasons for someone being town or scum, don’t enter exact scenarios.
He will just change cult into something else, same as he did turn alien into werewolf into cult.


Actually @ChopChop, that’s your problem - you are going into specific conspiracy theory scenarios.
You said I was alien with Soul, Werewolf with Wisp and Cult with GGhanqa.

Instead of throwing random names and factions, give me GENERAL reason why you scumread me, without entering specific scenario you focus on this time.

GENERAL reason why you started scumreading me on day 2 and locked on it so long to follow till today, searching for different options how I could be evil.

I’ll vote Tsumugi if for self preservation but I honestly think Ami is more likely evil for the simple fact their kill target at least claimed in Light doesn’t seem like a super towny shot.
Yes I know they flipped SK but that means that they wouldn’t have know Light was evil.
I think I have a hint at what Eevee is (Since he recended big which I didn’t even take as a proper claim earlier.)
Since I saw him ask others I leave them to figure it out but if am right I wish I had it as well instead of really being forced to take seer in an attempt to help town.

I have till 4pm my time to finish rereading so am asleep.

I will ask you then.

What am I?

Besides being human that is.

Honestly thought you softed named mason early in the game when we talked.

Or more mason without a partner

Silence is interesting I will be passing out again soon so won’t be relaible on responding

Sure, I can go with that claim :^)

Look, Min I get why you’re voting for TL I really do. But let me explain something called the PoE

The PoE is a list of people the town find scummy, when that group is formed you yeet through there when everyone is in the PoE is dead

Let me explain why. If we kill Tsumugi and they flip scum then that’s a net win for town. If they flip town then we kill whoever is next in line. If they flip scum then we continue. If everyone keeps flipping town then we know the PoE is busted

However if we go for everyone’s individual scumreads. Then the consequences of that can be really bad. Because if we kill someone who’s a member of the Tuen who isnt in the PoE then town is screwed as the ratio of towny to scummy players gets worse and worse. And if they do flip Scum? Who do we kill next?

Again I don’t think TL is acting all that towny but we need to think rationally about this and go with the PoE. If everyone in there dies then we have a stable enough town core that we can afford to kill TL.

1 Like

Votecount
Voted Count Accusers
Tsumugi 2/7 GGhana, Ami
TL 2/7 Surge, Min

2 Likes

Do you think tsumugi has a higher chance of flipping evil?

Yes, 100%

Your Responses.
Simple.

Most of them I received Day 2 were Dull and didn’t provide enough.
Today while your responses aren’t Dull, I feel like you have some agenda with your posting

Either way I sr them both so

/vote tsumugi

Yes? How’s that fake?

Read it properly.
I didn’t know, but you didn’t did know you faked your role unless you have brain trouble.