[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

society if min picks town watcher and gets a watch on surge n1 who still dies and outs light

1 Like

:joy_cat: imagine

I made good Night Kills.
I planned out allot in scum chat.

If people are annoyed at another player and you feel you can’t talk with them without irritating yourself, you focus on other things in the thread and get back to the one who irritates you when your able to.
I was Blacklisted for a completely different reason so quit talking BS.
Yes the main reason CRichard replaced out because of my almost tunnel on him.
That’s 1 guy and at the end I cool’ed off on him.
Not to mention I thought you and him were WW.

Yes I admit I affected the environment a bit.
But I wasn’t the entire cause of it.
If you don’t like me. Then leave it at that.
Don’t start BS.

I’m actually trying to be nice and listen to @Chloe
And not talk about the actual reason regarding by Blacklist.
If it will help maybe Chloe can tell you themselves in private chat.

@Mercenary
Can I request a host comment of this game?
So everything can be heard from your perspective.

Not comment more like Review/Feedback/Game Summary

I don’t know the word, I’m not an A+ Grammer student.

err have you heard of a domino effect because even if you did start it, the environment you created cause more argument and fighting so while you weren’t involved, you made it happen.

It’s obvious that I shouldn’t have joined the game anyway.
Enough said.

Anyway I’m not ever coming back to this sort of setup.
Sorry I’ve been burnt too hard to even think of trying it again.

1 Like

Ok.
But the same can be said about anyone who is heated or cause someone to get heated.

I didn’t accompany it a lot, the queue popped up at a really inconvenient time for me personally. Having the feeling of everyone screaming at me/eachother made me anxious. Also CRich being needlessly critical/dramatic in both the spectator chats and my Discord PMs. Not a pleasant experience overall.

But I do have mechanical feedback if I am to host it again.

Imo the doctors did well this game.

1 Like

Oh

Well

Doctor gang

Still surprised you didn’t tell me off for my comments in class card.

I think you shouldn’t show discarded cards… I think that caused a shit ton of discourse more then anything.

I also would find a way to make sure that, well, two of the same exact role and alignment cannot exist. Two mafia psychotroopers is disgusting.

I guess maybe also don’t make lone scum exist? Soul being alien gf from the start was something he probably never had a chance of winning especially wtf the one game factional kill.

In gortas case, you should just turn ww into an nk alignment over a groupscum one. Like werewolf from tos kinda. Just make it so group type mafia classes don’t spawn and only one person picks it (such as in soul and gorta)

Maybe add arsonist to the pool. You obviously don’t have to.

It wasn’t in this game thank god but I think black goo is incredibly broken and should not exist as if someone rands it they can quite literally loophole and say “everyone visit me and get converted” and day can end on n1.

Maybe…add a jailor? At the same time scum jailor is broken so obviously that’s a good and bad idea.

Well remember that Black Goo is Town

Meaning you also have to draw a Cult card to make it work

Yes

But

It’s still cringe

fwiw almost every problem you’re all listing is a problem with the actual setup which merc didnt make

although i think letting the same cards roll multiple times might be a thing that isn’t normal which let silly things like double psychotrooper and double seer and 1000 doctors happen

great ideas/grand ideas are always shitshows tho

Ohh

Yeah actually ur right

I guess this is more of a cosmetic suggestion I guess?