[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

I’m just gonna give you a free pass on this.

Personally I think Judas would be a lot more fun. As for the entire read pushing thing, It’s something I can agree with.

Could you tell me where did it come from.

Knowing Eli, it’s probably NAI.

As for Apprentice, Idk.

Wanna discuss about this read?

I find they arent really trying to lurk of fly under the radar. And much like whysper they correct people and push reads that make sense. And they do it in a natural way rather than a wolf trying to appear like good townie

no

well ok then.

Why do you think it’s wolfy?

all of the quotes in that post would suggest he isn’t town

he constantly complains about townplay on this site and as whysper points out he also complained that he has hardly been scum

so when given the opportunity to choose his alignment, taking both of these things into consideration, why would he not choose scum?

Let’s considers the possibilities that he can choose.

Town
Faction Scum
Survivor
Condemer
Judas
Saulus
SK

Looking at your logic, you’ll think he wouldn’t choose town, so now that out of the question.

The question for you becomes more will he choose survivor or just scum.

he has indicated not only that he doesn’t want to be town, but also that he wants to be specifically scum

I mean CRich just had a scum game recently. I would personally think that he would choose Judas if he had the chance.

this is a very strange post ngl

What are your other reads?

That’s eevee for ya

I want you to read Soul in Deus Ex because in that game I had a day of questioning Soul (Soul was deflecting questions) and then I went boom the next day. So I think Soul has some scum equity for refusing to answer questions.

I mean, Min did have more agenda and focus to their posts post-conversion, so yeah.

I will

That game was botched for me because of my work schedule and I wouldn’t base much of a read from Deus Ex. Deus Ex is a special theme to me because it’s one of my favorite games as of the last few months. I already knew a bit of the lore and wanted to get more involved with that theme even if I was town. I don’t have as much enthusiasm this time around. I’m going to play to the best of my ability, but I am not as excited for this game. Deus Ex was my best town game so far (besides that one game I got towncored)

So what do you think of Soul now?

Oh yeah Arctic

Order them based on what you think CRich would choose for me.

gorta claims that he discarded town tracker because he chose something stronger but i’m really not convinced. someone else said that tracker would be a better investigative than most others with the amount of scum factions and i have to say i agree, so gorta is scumlean for me

i’m not going to act like i have any idea what was going on between eevee and soul (lol)

gghana went from sending fluff posts to being a lot more serious, i wonder why? it seems like he was trying to actually get people to do stuff after realising contribution was dropping, but this could have been to gain credibility himself. either way i like this

i have no idea about min

a lot of people are just sending fluff (amelia, tsumigi) and i have no idea what to infer from this

I like Arctic.

I dont, i am the opposite of liking this

not good enough, anything else?

Arctic, if CRich is SK who do you think he kills tonight?

I mean if there is a Doc they should be on me because I’m their backup.