[SFM] Vanilla Mafia Mafia Mafia(TM) - Serial Killer Win! ...wait, who?

not really defensive or focusing on defending my slot.

i just want you to have reasoning to push me so i can gouge intentions and actually pick apart your push.

I donā€™t necessarily believe Geyde is scum, but I have seen his move before in a previous game (that mind you, everyone had him townread where I pinned him scumlean) and I wanted to make sure his push is genuineā€¦which at this moment im not convinced of.

It was defensive as in you tried you hardest to discredit it as much as possible

I donā€™t beleive the push had much credit and wanted to make that clear.

you canā€™t just say ā€œX badā€ as any alignment.

quote posts i made and say why they come from scum.

Marshal you know full well that Iā€™m too fucking good at gutreading you

usually you gutread me later.

after seeing more than 3 posts from me.

Are you just cashing in your ā€œgutread marshalā€ tokens to shamelessly agendapush?

No Iā€™m just getting better

Wasnā€™t anything firm either, but your reaction makes it pretty confident

you arent.

because honestly it does not feel like you actually want to improve at all. you just push and hope that you are right.

just give reasoning to your post please. what about my reaction is scummy.

again, let me re-iterate. anyone can say this about anyone

this is literally super fucking easy and if you actually want to improve give any semblance of logic or thought in your posts

I didnā€™t like the post you made my gut said it was scummy so I said marshal scum. Your reaction was garbage

what about my reaction was garbage.

give 3 things that i did that are indicative of scum marshal.

It was so defensive for no reason

All I said was Marshal scum and you wrote a paragraph

reasons marshals reaction bad, from derps:

  1. It was overly defensive, wrote a long reply when all derps said was ā€œmarshal badā€

Not at all

I generally use it when I think someone is scummy but only marginally

Thatā€™s my reason

To be fair, he seems to be trying a new approach where heā€™s not immediately deemed scum and then mislynched. I wonā€™t put him as a Townlean because of it quite yet, but its a much better approach than what he previously takes. I wonā€™t fault him for recognizing a weakness in play and improving.

so you think this interaction indicates scum me.

Yeah

I do however think ā€œoverly defensiveā€ isnā€™t the case reason for deeming someone scum. Everyone is going to defend themselvesā€¦its NAI.