But you can. There is no way nothing has pinged you among all the posts you did read.
Townread from pretty much nowhere as Geyde said, with meaningless fluff to ājustifyā it
If you want Iāll swap to Frost before I sleep but do you think Soul flips scum here Vul?
Bucko, all the posts I did read are posts I can barely remember except for the more recent ones
Like I said, I think Soul/Frost are almost equally likely to flip scum and Iām willing to go for Soul. However, I want to go for Frost over Soul because people have been lowkey ignoring Frost and I think thatās indicative of him being scum. Hardly anyone wants to push him and I donāt understand why.
And thatās why Iām Scumread in most of the games Iām in
Seriously though, I want to hear the explanation for Frost
People have pretty much said it already, I donāt believe the townslip either. āSuperpower is confirmed town.ā So he kinda agreed with the assertion that he thought I was the superpowerā¦ then in hindsight, it would mean he has just outed me to the scumteam (he hasnāt, but if I was town superpower, that would be exactly what happened).
I think Soul dug a hole under his feet. The superpower thing doesnāt make logical sense even if he really did think the superpower was town.
Ehh resistance to Frost lynch makes me want to kill it, but soulās behaviour/fake townslip makes me not want to let that live either.
So he thinks Iām confirmed town but still decided to read me and come to the conclusion Iām town?
This makes no sense.
If anything I feel soul is more likely to flip scum here so he should be TKād (less chance of guilt if this game has guilty viges) and we lynch soul who is slightly less chance to flip scum just because he could just be a super tired not thinking townie who had no clue what he was saying
Theory:
If heās town and I really am the town superpower (Iām obviously not but bear with me): Soul is attracting attention to me and making a read on me for no reason. In that world, he already knows my alignment, I donāt know his. The only reason I can think of would be for me to read him as town, but that also makes no sense because in that scenario, I would easily be able to tell who knows Iām the town superpower and who doesnāt. Meaning, nobody would need to read me in order to get a townread from me. Thatās also why having a town superpower would not be balanced, but I digress.
If heās scum, he knows Iām town - so surely he has a reason to read me and conclude Iām town. 1. towncred 2. potential pocketing 3. being correct. In that scenario, he does not know Iām the superpower, but he does know Iām town - so reading me makes sense.
TL;DR From a town POV, Soulās behavior makes absolutely no sense to me. From a scum POV, it does make sense.
Itās still possible Soul is a very confused townie, but I just donāt understand his motivation and his arguments from a town POV.
1 Like
Okay, good, we have plurality.
Iām fine with voting Soul too, but Frost needs to die.
Why wonāt anyone answer my question? :^)
Iām willing to vote Soul, itās just that I want to know which personās the better lynch
Scum know who their superpower is, but the superpower does not know them I believe.
But from Frostās PoV if he thought you were Town Superpower (maybe he thought you claimed it?) and therefore, were confirmed town to him since he didnāt know there was no town superpower.
If he is town he made the read with a lack of information, thinking you were just a regular player.
If he was scum, he made the read knowing you were a townie and therefore, was trying to pocket you/act like hes contributing.
Maybe its a perspective slip: he knows youāre a townie, and we said town superpower so he was like Vulgard is confirmed town
Wrapping my head around this is extremely difficult.
The issue is that he read me as town superpower for no reason. If heās town, he has no reason to put that in the open. If heās scum, thatās an oddly specific read to make.