I’ve been thinking about Alice tbh, honestly as an alternative to Ozz/Kai scumteam but as a Kai/Alice scumteam. Alice would’ve come up with the gambit to ‘clear’ Kai and simultaneously pocket Ozz for the rest of the game. It’s weaker yes, but still valid.
Alice just seems so quick to clear people this game its unnerving, yet I’m scared of lynching her because I always misread her.
Although he did jump on the badwagon, he was scum reading Ozz and he said if you’re sus of him to check him, which I don’t think scum would say
Are you saying you think someone is more likely to be scum than Marshal based on your reaction check? If that’s true, make a case about them and I’ll consider lynching that player.
I’m saying that because you mentioned intent to look into Marshal, but that you also have a potential scum. Which makes it sound like Marshal isn’t that scum because you haven’t looked into it yet.
Just clarifying.
I think I’ll ISO Alice tomorrow, I don’t have the mental stamina to do that now and I am considering bed.
Does anyone want anymore takes on events before I go?
Do you think clearing a lot of people as BD is advantageous to cult!Alice? Both Cults get this information and by extension, both Cults can PoE the other Cult members.
I’m asking within the context of cult!Alice. Do you think cult!Alice would do that?
Clearing has different merit based on the game state and your alignment, which is why I’m asking for input.
I mean easiest explanation is pocketing, but she gets herself townread by not being aggressive and showing read progression, though only an illusion if it is from scum!Alice.
Both cults still want to kill us right now though.
It’s just decreasing the PoE so we can find scum. Bad thing is that I really thought Arete was being scummy af, but now the only way for them to be cult is if Italy is their scummate
Also, Alice, if she is from the three member cult right now, could be simultaneously trying to clear her scumbuds.
I really don’t know about this game, every time I think I’m on to something the gamestate gets flipped on its head and my various thoughts on people are scrambled.
However, I’m adamant that having most active players supposedly cleared is too easy and I think one of these cleared active players are scum be it Alice, Kai, Ozz or Marshal (i know hes scumread but hes active so).
DatBird is an option however, and I haven’t seen anything from him that makes me think he is town.
Exactly. Which is why BD clearing a large number of people informs the other Cult members where to shoot if they agree with the clears.
Basically, clearing a lot of people as BD… well, it’s a double-edged sword. It gives us the opportunity to not trust scum. But it also gives scum the opportunity to target their mutual enemies before turning on each other.
That’s why I’m asking if you think cult!Alice would do that right now. Who does clearing a lot of BD benefit more at this stage of the game?
Also, remember that we have been flip-flopping between multiple wagons and all of them seem to gain traction easily, until the person being accused defends themselves.
It feels like Cult is attempting to steer our lynches and we can’t notice it. The question is whether they are attempting to lynch BD or each other… which makes me wonder about Alice’s intentions even more.
In my opinion, clearing BD in this situation makes it harder for Cult to lynch among BD, so… if I’m reading into this correctly, Alice is BD in my eyes.
Unless Alice is trying to lynch other Cult members while killing BD at night - a simultaneous battle.
Which do you think is more likely?
