No I should not because I don’t spectate games with you, don’t rely on meta, and this is literally my second game with you.
That argument doesn’t really make sense – being hard on Alice is… understandable, I guess, she plays both scum and town well – but being paranoid about Vulgard sounds like a joke.
Vulgard is literally the most obvious town when he is town, and when he gets scum he just slips on his own words. You should know that from his game history – not to mention that I literally mentioned it myself:
I have played Anime FM, Ritual Mafia 4, Hell in the Cell D6, Insurgency, SFoL 60, SFoL 61 (partially), and bastard++. Hopefully I am not missing any
if we do NKA under the impression that arete mechanically can’t be the NK, so they didnt kill vulgod
who attacks vulgard n2?
im absolutely confused ;-;
MASSCLAIM TIME
we’re beyond that
I’ll only openclaim if Napoleon decides it’s appropriate.
But eh, at this point it’s basically obvious.
The current thing I am conflicted on with Italy is that a bleed could be fakeable, but Italy is actually playing and they could only be the convert or claiming the bleed as MM. I think someone is miscleared
Let me get his readlist.
i want to get everyone’s hardclaims
or at least someone give me a claims list
Hell, I am probably misclearing someone
sigh
There is ONE NK Arete can’t mechanically be, why are we assuming that clears them of being NK?
I think Italy is fine, you guys kept saying the bleed would have been a waste, so I am not sure if Italy would do such a thing.
Town:
TBE
katze
Anstreim
AreteJane
These people are town, from my perspective. Jane I feel the least strongly about and am the most likely to re-evaluate later. It’s possible there is a convert among them, but highly unlikely, at least where I currently stand.
intensify
sirderpsalot
modeshifterLolneutclaims. I’m willing to say Seth is a town-aligned Senex based on the posts of his which I’ve seen, but he needs to use his ability.
Wolves / PoE:
an_gorta
appelI don’t have strong opinions there just yet. The wagons smell like TvT, but I have tangible reasons to townread many other people and I don’t have strong reasons to townread them . I don’t think Appel is NK. I will have to read her d2 posts to figure out if she can be groupscum. It’s not impossible for her to be converted, given her pretty good showing in Short Fuse V.
Cloned
This guy literally claimed Scorned, and his posts have been unimpressive. I do think he’s been doing his towntell, which is why I wouldn’t lynch him today, but I can’t reasonably take him out of the PoE if he continues to disappoint. With all due respect.
Napoleon
King. I think it’s more likely he’s town than it is likely for him to be scum, but again. I need to figure it out by deepreading them.
I think there definitely has to be a wolf (1+) among the neut claims. We have three neut claims and only 1-2 slots for non-killer neuts.
Along with:
To put this in order:
Arete
TBE
katze
AnstreimJane
ModeShifter
Intensify
SirDerpsALotClonedcheese
Appelsiini
an_gorta_prataiIf wagons are W/W, it would explain why they seem frozen, actually. That’s one thing to consider.
TBA: Napoleon
If I were a non-Mind Flayer NK, then Vul wouldn’t be dead (because katze)
if I were a Mind Flayer NK, then Cloned would be dead (because Happy Hour + Redirection)
There is ONE NK Arete can’t mechanically be, why are we assuming that clears them of being NK?
well
i HHed them last night and there doesnt seem to be a missing nightkill
All of the NKs but one (?) are occupy immune. HH removes that occupy immunity and occupies them, if they were redirected as anything else they would just be occupied and not kill anyone.
And Vulgard died.
Wait I thought it’s only empowered Mind Flayer that would get redirected under HH?
Wait… did I misread something?
everyone’s talking in ToL terms that i dont know ;-;
halp
if I were inexplicably-non-empowered MF then the ‘Vul wouldn’t be dead’ thing still applies
if arete is MM then they hard fucking bussed crichard and… very unlikely
arete could be convert but thats not really our priority