SFoL 61 - Castle of the Blood God - Ended Early, will be Re Randed(15/16)

[Napoleon]

Almost at 500

[TheBlueElixir]

@CRichard564

Wait are we still sure the group scum faction is BD even though Alice admitted the red check was a reaction test? We’re still not sure if this is a BD/Unseen game yet.

nah i was just looking at the card

@Napoleon

His N1 result will give him legitimacy. If he’s LHF, we can help verify his claim

true. Though there are probably other ways to do that - as in another investigation elsewhere. might take this as a reason nonetheless

@Napoleon

You talked about anti-claim? I’ve looked over some of the anticlaimers (like zealot and inquisitor and mind flayer) and I don’t think it will be easy to alleviate the danger of it. We already have some claims and other softs (I could probably guess what class a few of us are claiming here), and all the anticlaimers would already have their ways of already taking advantage of this situation or the fact that gorta claimed investigative

not as much as this. Inq/Mindflayer cant take advantage and zealot isn’t an anticlaim

the way to alleviate it is if the NK is dead

@clonedcheese

I again don’t entirely believe your claim

did i miss it

@Napoleon

the information he would likely present wouldn’t be clearing.

bruh he literally said it wouldn’t remove em from the PoE and its probably not a recheck so yeah

@Arete

not going to lie I’m highkey confused about what Gorta could even be , Fanatic and Damsel would both have clearing (or condemning) information, High Priestess and Seeker might or might not but any class type grouping and/or track result is at least somewhat informative

I was thinking of doing this

but i didn’t think it was +EV to do in thread?

there are a million possibilities - n1 watchful eye, n1 soul links, n1 reconciliation, literally every seeker abil

@anon6348071

…Is it really only glaringly obvious to me?

yes

[Napoleon]

@TheBlueElixir

bruh he literally said it wouldn’t remove em from the PoE and its probably not a recheck so yeah

I misworded that. I meant clearing for themselves.

[clonedcheese]

@Arete

given that you appear to be basing several of your reads on that assumption, why are you assuming that?

look above

im held under duress to not speak of it

but i don’t see any evidence that would counter my suspicion

[TheBlueElixir]

oopsie

but if the info aint critical it probably wont anyway, though you already said that

[Napoleon]

But if he is scum, he’s forced to claim information relating to Italy.

[TheBlueElixir]

if scum W/W this might matter

V/W, no matter whos the V and who’s taking the L it wouldn’t really be insightful

if starting scum gotta be the converter anyway

[clonedcheese]

@anon6348071

Still waiting for Cloned to answer your question, Napoleon.

what is this question you speak of

@anon6348071

@anon6348071

Still waiting for Cloned to answer your question, Napoleon.

Actually, that was Arete’s question.

wat

@SirDerpsAlot

Has Italy posted

@Napoleon

I don’t think so

@SirDerpsAlot

/Vote Italy

angry cheese noises

[TheBlueElixir]

@Arete

given that you appear to be basing several of your reads on that assumption, why are you assuming that?

@anon6348071

@anon6348071

Still waiting for Cloned to answer your question, Napoleon.

Actually, that was Arete’s question.

boop

[Napoleon]

@TheBlueElixir

if scum W/W this might matter

V/W, no matter whos the V and who’s taking the L it wouldn’t really be insightful

if starting scum gotta be the converter anyway

It’s much easier to corner him this way if he’s wolf. If he’s scum he can prepare a fake result on another player that he wishes. He can’t prepare one in this way - Jane’s logs force him to make a claim on Italy, and I want him to come out with it before its public.

[Napoleon]

@clonedcheese

what is this question you speak of

Arete asked the question: Why are you basing your reads on a W!Gorta?

[clonedcheese]

cool
so i answered that

[TheBlueElixir]

@Napoleon

It’s much easier to corner him this way if he’s wolf. If he’s scum he can prepare a fake result on another player that he wishes. He can’t prepare one in this way - Jane’s logs force him to make a claim on Italy, and I want him to come out with it before its public.

eh

he’s still now trapped to make a claim that specifically makes Italy look okay while being an invest

unless gorta would like to claim red. immune?

[Napoleon]

It also needs to be consistent with his behaviour. He said that he could potentially get a lot of information off Alice and I want to see why he thought that.

[TheBlueElixir]

wish we knew the scumfaction

with a lot of invests a BD game would go smoother

meanwhile unseen have at most 2 members sus every night with some members abil to hide a 2nd or even all 3 members for a night

useless to speculate but I like to think on these

[Napoleon]

I don’t think it’s useless to speculate. We could try, I don’t think we have enough information though.

[TheBlueElixir]

would it be cool if I softed by saying which faction converting me would make me stronger

hm

no I don’t want to be converted actually so no

[TheBlueElixir]

pick a number 1-10

[Napoleon]

I choose 9

[Napoleon]

500th post