I’m not convert hunting I’m just saying that Unseen is a possibility as well and bounty is not truly confirmable if he were to do so tomorrow.
People get too caught up in mechanical clearing.
I agree with you on the convert hunting stuff
Id say you, nicolas, isabel and emma I like the investment
thomas for the reason u know already
I remember liking marys vibe when I was Isoing them I would still like ppl I Isod to respond to me first
1 Like
Give me your take on Edmond.
Also I want you to GTH give me a wolf. Surely there is someone who has pinged you in a scummy way other than Thomas with the NE thing.
1 Like
they seem invested into solving at least thats the impression I got while scrolling through the thread
I would say in helen, sarah, susan
in that order
they are not strong because I will most likely re-evaluate them after they respond with defense to me
Finishing the ISO dives
Thomases… Well, what is there to say about it.
Thomas 1, compulsive spammer, troll, claimed observer and a kill from Sarah.
Thomas 2, started by retracting the claim which is good.
This pretty much says exactly why I have been struggling. I apologise but my style is very meta based so I am finding myself out of my comfort zone.
Thomas feels like he is rolefishing a bit which is not great but I could just be misinterpreting his words. Idk whether anyone else feels this way too or not.
Totally ignores Alice in this bit which is unusual to me.
I finally want to touch on the bleed. I doubt it comes from scum because Thomas 1 was highly antitown and Thomas 2 is less antitown but a bit actually scummy. Why bleed instead of set up mislynch fodder?
Andy townleaning Thomas felt weird, as if he wanted to force content and look contrarian.
A lot of the posts were wastes of interactions with Thomas too which made me feel quite unsure of the intentions behind it.
Could this be a scumslip? It felt weirdly out of place for Andy to say that Thomas essentially could not be scum to me.
I like Andy D2 though, it feels good to me. The claim makes sense with their adamance of not being K/O.
Isabel, very nice start to the iso. Feels like a confident town leader. I need to hear more of them D2 but I found literally nothing that I found suspicious. Will quote my favourite posts later but this is a moderate town read.
Nicolas is one of the players I remember liking D1. They were a very verbal player who actively contributed, thy responded to reads. Mentioned liked and disliked posts. Day 2 they have felt comfortable in thread thus far.
This slot is my highest town (Thus far, as I have not gotten to Ivo yet. Yes, I know Ivo is claiming prince
Gilbert is one of the highest posters and from what I have said thus far it seems that I like the higher posters but I am not a fan of this slot. The Gilbert and Thomas 1 interactions were weird since Gilbert was being defensive. Honestly one of the only posts I like from the slot is that the d2 king lynch is bad… but, even that is not amazing because it is fairly logical. Nothing noteworthy.
Nullscum.
Alice is just pure imo. Alice has done good reads, picked up on others who are slacking and basically is ruling with an iron first. I think this is also just a good example of a town leader.
They dealt with the Thomas slot quickly and moved on. They had an idea which I had which was D1 GT although I know it would not have let me execute… and seem to have contributed by questioning everyone else.
First few Ivo posts were not good at all. Their interactions with Thomas were unimpressive. The individual ISO reads were not amazing but were at least something to tithe the slot over.
The worst thing in the ISO would be this since I saw about the bleed claim D2 by Thomas as it could seem like Ivo had planned it in advance or perhaps was a neutral signalling a safe kill to scum.
I like the way that Ivo dealt with claiming though at least in the end. But beforehand, yeah, there was plenty of bad looks to the slot
Edmond is the final slot I need to touch on, I think and is the highest posted slot out of all alive players. This is another slot I remember some of from D1.
I dislike how Edmond started off being not at all serious. Does not care to win, seems quite pessimistic too but it is not necessarily scummy.
One thing I want to say about this slot is, I want them to just respond to multiple things together instead of so many smaller posts because it is irritating and could be interpreted as wanting to seem like they are contributing a bit too much.
Thankfully, however, the bits itself are not too bad. Though still around a hundred posts into this ISO, some of them were not serious which is a bad look. If I had to GTH this slot, I would say town but I want them to only take things seriously and have more sustenance to the posts instead of a line or two.
I think you’re conflating my statement that Peter “looks better” with Peter is confirmed town which I never said is the case.
If they are scum, they have to be N1 convert as starting cult/unseen don’t have bounty ability N1.
1 Like
I didnt like how they had a lot of reads in readlist without any progression or reasoning
referencing this
1 Like
I have mech info that Susan is BD.
4 Likes
okay
We all do. They died N1.
Well, the insistence of Gilbert on scumreading the dead BD means that he/his faction at least didn’t kill Susan.
oh
going to sleep any last questions?
/vote Jane
Mind pointing out the rolefishing you see?
Thomas is obvious town imo
Bleed came from scum. I don’t see Thomas being ML’d, especially since they seem to be a very strong player and I’m sure they could get themself off the stand.
Town bleed on Thomas would have happened d1, if anything.
This big post from Alan is alright, and I can’t find anything horribly wrong with it on the surface, but it still doesn’t change the fact that I think this is an EK.
Will try to read this post in detail again later, see if I missed anything.
Dude three people have done similar things
Andy, Peter, Gilbert
Imagine if its that simple
voat
| Vote target | Voted by | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Geoffrey_Bailey | Jane_Drayton | 1/9 |
| Jane_Drayton | Nicolas_Adams, Peter_Carew, Thomas_The_Second | 3/9 |
| Helen_Harte | Isabel_Savage, Emma_Maison, Ivo_Wake | 3/9 |
| Isabel_Savage | Sarah_Lacey | 1/9 |
| Alan_Atlee | Mary_Savill | 1/9 |
| Gilbert_Lovell | Alice_Alard | 1/9 |
| Not Voting | Gilbert_Lovell, Geoffrey_Bailey, Andy_Bernard, Alan_Atlee, Edmond_Bailey, Helen_Harte | 6 |