They just copied the pings from me (like I said, so sorry, I had some reason to use them I think), but I don’t think they are able to make their own (non-copied) pings
Out of all of these posts about Thomas and complaining this one is the most genuine. It’s probably fakable, but this anger feels genuine and town motivated.
I feel like it’s NAI that they continued to reply to Thomas this soon. Like everyone was doing it before they realized Thomas was a troll and by the time I made it to the thread everyone had Thomas ignored.
This is a very towny thought in my opinion. The bolded part more so seems towny. Scum wouldn’t care if the threadstate is shit, so that statement gives Mary town points in my opinion.
These thoughts ooze towniness. They have a genuine tone when solving and they are actually solving Conclusion
This slot is 90% town. I don’t see a world in which this is ever scum. They seem to have independent reads, want to solve, and show some interest in the game.
Just realized I missed a lost of posts since it jumped me down to the bottom when I hit reply.
Blargh. Mechanics talk.
Don’t talk mechanics unless it’s actually important.
Every little thing you say is impactful, no matter how small you think it is.
Noticed as well, and agreed.
Noticed as well, and agreed, again.
Honestly really really like that you’re noticing these things that I noticed, but you’re actually able to put them into words.
Expand on this more please. Your answer to Emma doesn’t really do it.
Why do you lightly scumread them?
Wish you didn’t post this until Ivo explained.
However I see where you’re coming from with Geoffrey.
The only thing is that I get more of “newbtown” vibes from them than I do mafia. I can expand on this in a bit. I’m finding myself busier today than expected.
Why did you trend Sarah up?
This post gives me newbtown feelings. I just see this as more of an pure villager who is stating their thoughts as they come, even though some of them are useless and surface-level wolfy.
I guess it’s a TWTBAW read? And that’s not good of me.
If I ignore my thought that this is an inexperienced player I can see how their behavior is scummy.
Also this interested me yesterday, and I forgot to point it out:
I don’t quite understand why they went for the Sarah ISO out of everyone else in the game. Sarah had very few posts and IMO did not have enough content to form a read on them.
But this feels like genuine frustration at people not replying to his reads - and, while it can come from either alignment, it makes me feel like this is an inexperienced villager wanting people to appreciate that he is putting in effort. It’s frustrating when you make a big post that goes unnoticed! I’ve been there.
I have to go for a while.
Hold me to the things I said - if I’m forgetful.
Why are we focused on Thomas? Anyone who still interacts with Thomas after pulling this shit off twice in a row is >rand w in my opinion. Thomas should probably be replaced out today if they keep it up