The way Peter talks about Mary makes me think there is no way theyāre the same alignment.
There is a wolf in Peter/Mary from their interactions.
I think Mary is more likely town than Peter, though as we saw with Glibert thatās why we donāt pre flip.
Your slot actions donāt make sense to me a from a town PoV.
Maryās action on the other I find more like to come from a townie.
If Andy flips NK, then theyāre 100% starting town here.
I read Jane as town and Iām not sure how is Jane scum from your PoV.
Though Iām willing to change my mind.
See when I read people I think āWhy did this person do this action, and from which alignment does it make more sense to do it fromā.
See what I said about if the actions make more sense in helping fulfill a town wincon or scum wincon.
If Mary were Cult, then I would think theyād try to cover for the NK for a few days at least so they have more night kills, yet outing suspected NK makes more sense from town than scum.
Andy was a slot I never trusted and Mary outing it early pretty much confirmed my suspicion that they arenāt starting town.
this also, in a way, assumed āperfectā play from both parties. You have to keep in mind mistakes will be made and not everyones actions are going to make sense for their specific alignemnt all the time
Itās a possibility I havenāt ruled out 100%.
Though as I said before, I donāt think you and Mary are the same alignment here based on your interactions.
Of course, they can still be converted even if they were starting town when they found the NK.