I think he means Andy.
2 Likes
Jane:
Summary
Early reads, small explanation seems fine. Early push or at least a little bit of a take on someone that isnāt lol Thomas I like this starter good entrance gives a bit of a push and spotlight to someone.
This seems fine, I found it weird that Geoffy would have to openly state this imo instead of just openly trying to fix things or improve/make it clearer that they were in fact town. I donāt know it does kind of feel like scum potentially grovelling or trying to act casual about a early scum read without actually doing anything Jane has also helped me to realise that Geoffy might be a important slot that needs careful examination.
I personally think itās a normal reaction from some players to get defensive with scum reads. I am going to tend to try to look at the other players POV and why Iād be a scum read. Either way I donāt really think being a bit defensive is Ai, I guess it depends on the reaction and why they are defensive.
Jane is actually early town for me
well I mentioned above
I didnāt really memorize ppl because solving activity is really weak read in anon game and I usually focus on few people at once when making read
itās just gonna be smth I am gonna keep in mind when re-reading them later
Iām also mind melding Gilbert as I also slight village read Andy.
This seems to be a good sign.
Skimm reading peter Isos boring nothing great contributed Null Poe ez
Redoing Susan reads when I get to them, pretty much didnāt have much posts when I did early reads.
Anyway back to reading
Did you say Peter?
I put that slot as null as I didnāt see anything AI from their slot.
I find it troubling there are quite a few slots which arenāt doing much D1.
Every day is important for discussion. It isnāt good to waste discussion time.
Susan seems like a genuine town to me.
Though his/her semi-fluff is 
Iām getting a bit confused with all the alts so bear with me here going to try.
Yeah peter slot just exists right now.
Oh no I slipped as the hunter I said bear
Itās ok. I can see youāre trying here which is a good sign.
Not saying what I think should be done with Peter for now as we need to beware of anti claims.
1 Like
I was working on that before I went to sleep in my chair.
So far I have Emma as a likely town, Thomas as a reluctant TR, and I think our king is good
No other reads?
I can believe Emma and Alan the King as both town.
Thomas on the other hand, Iām scum leaning them. Still there is a slight possibility that they are a tunnelled villager here.
I find it a lot easier to read someone based on who they are thatās why I might be struggling a little more here.
As the game develops things might get better I think I just need to spend time sitting down and looking at the thread instead of slipping in here and there giving thoughts on whatās going on.
Iām sure a lot of people are in a similar boat here though.
Oh my. We only have 4 and a bit hours left until D1 ends.
If you have anything important to say D1, say it now.
Honestly no, give me a bit and I should be able to read everyone today
The Thomas snap read is based on tone more than anything.
Has your read stayed the same or has that changed?
I was trying my best not to fluffā¦
Anywho, I gave a couple reads earlier, dunno if you missed em. I do like your entrance into the thread, some more solving is definitely nice. Iām was originally a bit split on Ivo, but Iām definitely liking them more, as well as their wallposts, and their self-initiative to improve their reads (such as reminding themselves to re-look at my slot.) I donāt feel like dealing with Thomas, they either need to be mechtown or dead. I havenāt really seen much out of Geoffrey thatās pinged me, so Iāll have to do an ISO of them too see whatās got everyone worked up. Lastly, Iām not sure if I like Isabelās interaction with my slot. Their posts all game have felt kinda meh, and then they just kinda have a mind meld that I didnāt even notice as their entire read.