[SFoL] SFoL 48: Hand of Byzantium II - (3/16) - Completed - The Unseen, the Necromancer, and the Insurgent Win!

[MathBlade]

Why are you advocating for lynching someone you don’t townread?

[Htm]

I agree but Max needs to be pressured.

[MathBlade]

Scumread*

[Solic]

@Geyde

@BlueStorm do you have anything else to add to thread/

@Geyde

I want to focus on Blue since that opener that was just IIoA with nothing to add is fairly strange

@Geyde

Lowkey Blue might have scumslipped

@Geyde

Everyone who hasn’t made an active contribution to thread plus Blue

@Geyde

This reads a bit Scum to me if were under the assumption that Priestess is a killing neut.

Blue is under a different impression of what Priestess is. I don’t think this logic makes sense.
Basically ‘why is blue saying this’ and ‘what is their logic’.

Geyde was pushing on Blue day 1 and largely dropped his push day 2. Right after conversion night.

[MathBlade]

But it won’t matter as scum know we are lynching Possessed.

[Emilia]

Why do you think I do that

[MathBlade]

Here imho look at Marcus’s reasoning

[MathBlade]

Because you said you don’t scumread me. Then you’re suggesting to lynch me

[Emilia]

ikr

[Htm]

You are making me unsure now…

[Solic]

@Possessed

If Geyde builds a townblock and he’s starting Scum were in trouble lol

Here it reads like Possessed is also scared of Geyde, so it fits with that narrative.

@Possessed

So assuming Priestess is who I think they are, I think it’s worth keeping them alive. They’re not terrible to have in this situation.

This reads a bit Scum to me if were under the assumption that Priestess is a killing neut. Why would a town killing neut be good? Its not facts what type of neut she is, but the idea she would be pro-town isn’t set in stone yet.

@Possessed

Not Blue, most of town is under that assumption.

Early distancing.

@Possessed

Well that was a very honest response from Maxwell. I find it very townish that he admits he forgot his N1 action, which is information that would typically put someone on a watch list had he not shared.

I think if we can determine what type of game this is, his confession could be a tell.

Similar argument applies. I can see both worlds tbh. We need them here to be honest.

@BlueStorm

Who do you think is MM?

@Possessed

Let us in your head Marg because I’m not getting it either.

@Possessed

I get the concept behind that, but wouldn’t that be an even bigger telltale for scum than just…not claiming at all? You’re drawing unnecessary attention and having HB run around in circles with you.

These posts make Marge look better.

@Possessed

I think a check on her wouldn’t hurt, but I strongly believe Marg here and I doubt they are scumteam.

There is also this post though. Of course Marge would survive a check as MM and they have fakeclaimed Observer before.

This one is better then again. It doesn’t sound engineered.

@Possessed

I want to believe Marg isn’t pulling our strings here based on my reads of her. I also read her incorrectly last game I was in with her, so…maybe I’m reading her oppositely.

[Solic]

This game isn’t solved yet, we can’t just rest on our laurels, just because we get 2 scum to drop on one day, so what makes you think Blue is towny? Or should I ask Priestess from beyond the grave instead ^^?

@anon97870008

[Htm]

Priestess muted dead chat so I won’t be able to ask her.

[Emilia]

@Solic

makes you think Blue is towny?

Someone had greencheck on them

[Htm]

Wait Priestess wants to answer now.

[Solic]

Greencheck on a MM.

Yeah.

[Emilia]

It’s the kind greencheck that clears someone from being MM only

[Solic]

Oh is the greencheck: “I read them as town?”. Why? Who do you think are MM/NK then?

[Htm]

Priestess says he knew as Sentinel that Saint’s passive can’t be removed and called her out on that.

That’s why she thinks he is HoB.

[Emilia]

Look at roles and think what role can clear someone from being MM