[SFoL] SFoL 49: Triple Threat: Hand of Byzantium - Canned

[Icibalus]

Honestly, my gut says that Squid is village and I’m not sure why, which is why I’ve been leaving Squid alone up until now. Something about their tone seems to make me think she’s mislynch bait again, which is probably a neat explanation for why nobody’s talking about her.

This isn’t to say that I think Squid is clear or anything, merely that I’d like to se how she pans out before making a definite decision on how to read her.

Counterquestion: What do you think about Marcus? I feel he’s been neglected and there’s been a lot of token villagereads given to him for very little reason.

[Blizer]

@Icibalus

What do you think about Marcus? I feel he’s been neglected and there’s been a lot of token villagereads given to him for very little reason.

I would need to iso him and go through him to get a full out read, but from what ive seen, his stance on the FK vs Math was slightly towny, his Slip with the cabalist message felt quite genuine, so i do have a town gut read on him.

[Blizer]

Agreed to a point that he has been overlooked, but he has been in most major discussions aside from your chess talk with Fk.

[Firekitten]

denied

[Blizer]

@Marcus_Doodalee

Kitten
I think I know what is wrong with this post

You see, I think town HTM would be more likely to respond to “Did you read my classcard?” with something along the lines of “Yes, I actually did for once.” or “No, I didn’t actually lemme go do that real quick.” whereas this version has that crafted feel to it

“It’s prolly because I don’t read it.”
That seems so formal from HTM

“But I did read it this time”
You really read this post putting emphasis on the word ‘did’ here, and it feels like something you’d say to your english teacher when they ask you whether you read some book or article that was for homework or something.

It just feels unnaturally crafted, this is the kinda post I catch myself doing more often

His post on his stance with Htm during the initial Gladiate, with Htm`s Grammer being something that sticks out to him. Honestly, i dont know how to feel about it, cause i can see scum or town marcus making a post like this.

@Marcus_Doodalee

Is it bad that I disagree with this because gladiating HTM isn’t ballsy enough for scum! FK?

Believes that Scum FK would Gladiate a town leader, so Htm isnt a ballsy move. Dont think its a bad read, but its FK.

@Marcus_Doodalee

If HTM flips scum I will deathtunnel you like there’s no tomorrow

He says this to Solic, but this was a bit ago, so im not sure if his stance changed or not.

@Marcus_Doodalee

We have deduced he can only be the random unseen. Arbiter should be checking someone who has the most chance of flipping scum, FK has by mechanics alone proven to be none of the 5 scum slots. there is a 500% better chance of killing scum if the arbiter checks anyone else. This is just plain logic

Decent reasoning with Arbiter check around FK

@Marcus_Doodalee

should the arbiter actually check people who are scummy? seeing as they also kill them?

or should they check nullreads as hard defending scummy people is just going to signal to scum that they’re arbiter with a check on someone

This is interesting tbh. Hes wondering if the arbiter should check scummy people or people who are nullread. Almost 100% of the time you check nullreads with a cop check. Im taking note of this post, cause we can look at it for his motivation and tone.

[Firekitten]

Marcus is a wolf and I’m waiting for N3 to slay him unless he convinced me otherwise

@Marcus_Doodalee

[Firekitten]

Checking null reads is only something we did with a tailor in game

this guy is basically an addiontal lynch

[Blizer]

Dislike that he keeps on saying who the arbiter is. its scummy for sure.

@Marcus_Doodalee

Screw you and all your FPSing crap I’m sick of it, absolutely sick of it

Magnus literally OUTED that he was arbiter and you still want to stick with this bullshit, I’m going to make it my personal mission to death tunnel you and make sure you are lynched today because there’s no way you are shading me

This feels Forced af, ngl. Its a complete 180 on his stance with FK.

I find it super weird, cause he wasnt even showing his frustration with FK at any point, and if he did, it was very little.

[Blizer]

Marcus started off decent, then went a total 180 at around 120-130 posts into his iso

Like, god damn dude.

[Firekitten]

did we reallly bamboozle Everyone so hard

[Blizer]

Wait wut

[Firekitten]

we did it reddit

[anon97870008]

Chess again?

[Blizer]

Okay, that turns around my thinking on Marcus tbh.

Gonna Continue my ISO

[Firekitten]

no tic tac toe

[Blizer]

@Marcus_Doodalee

I agree with you that scum probably do think about fakeclaiming arbiter, but I don’t think that’s what the baulk of how good scum would go about it, when I think about scum fakeclaiming arb, I really don’t think it’s how possessed did it.

I can see Scum fake claiming Arbiter, or softing it, and the Real Arbiter wont speak up in fear of getting killed.

@Marcus_Doodalee

I’ve noticed it several times now. You seem to be unseen hunting more than anything else

Points this out to Math. Actually very good thing, cause scum would do selective scum hunting to get away as town. Marcus hasnt done anything so far when it comes to Selective Scum hunting.

@Marcus_Doodalee

There is something to be said about this however
Scum Math definitely knows how to continue shenanigans even after he has died
Why did he not consider the possibility now? That would indicate a town mindset

Believes Math to be town, due to his Resilient stance that FK was Judge (At the time). He scum math would set up the game to be thrown upside down if he flipped. Its a good read by him, and it doesnt feel forced.

@Marcus_Doodalee

here’s what I think healers should do

flip a coin on whether to heal priestess or not, if heads yes, if tails no and you instead heal someone you actually think is a nightkill target

If she dies two nights from now and we get a lot of doc claims something is VERY wrong

Stance on Priestess bleed and what healers should do

the 50/50 coin toss is a weird suggestion (I understand that the point of it is for the Healrs to WIFOM their heal). Other than that, post is fine.

[Blizer]

Posts feel natural, nothing looks forced (Aside from the FK cover). Reads are solid, progression is solid

@Icibalus I town read Marcus, as i feel like if he was scum, he would be much more careful about what hes saying, and about his reads

I feel like he would have hedged the FK and Htm gladiate if he was scum.

[SweetyCake]

JOHN CENA!
Lol came back from dinner here
OwO

[PoisonedSquid]

All the posts I’ve missed take too long to load, so I’m not reading them
What’s the tldr? And don’t tell me to read myself because the posts won’t stop loading, so I can’t

[DatBird]

We have a cabalist of two outed, HTM is currently the most voted out of the two of him.and FK, Priestess is claiming a bleed, and dont know how far back you were but Poss was supposedly not softing Arbiter