Well realistically Math could be either Unseen or Cult. Like FKs flip if town he can still be either, but if Unseen which is the only other option for FKs flip he is pretty likely cult. Either side would push FK at this point unless they are on the same team, because you would never bus FK it would be to awkward and he would prob fight it. Math’s pushes to me in the three main ones the FK push, the Geyde push, and the bleed push all feel wrong and not Village Idiot wrong, but blatantly wrong.
First his whole thing with FK honestly just seems to be grasping at straws and says he keeps getting shut down and no one will listen to him. Like Im sorry but I have no mechanical proof FK is town, but his meta reminds me heavily of the color game we played together on MS. In that game he was pretty much a townleader and orchestrated the lynches, but you could say he did that in VCFM which is true, but idk I got a weird feeling in that game that told me he was scum and I didn’t have that in the MS game or this one currently. Now does it mean his Gladiate was a good move, not really. Like I know HTMs meta kind is him being scummy, but he hasnt really fought or push anyone that makes me feel like hes scum. Now Im not 100% sure on him, I would say like 65% chance hes scum, while FK I would say is 25% chance hes scum. So I feel like the HTM lynch is the right way to go.
Now the Geyde read I havent really seen any reasons at all he kinda just seemed to suddenly say that when Solic asked about the deus volt, and the best reason I have seen from Math on why Geyde is scum is lack of oomph of town effort and…
I even pointed to the conversation between you Ici and Geyde where I felt like Town!Geyde really showed. Like again this feels really unfounded and seems to be a push with 0 motivation. Now the only thing Geyde hasn’t done that was his town meta, is that he hasnt posted a graph pic of whos town yet, but he hasnt done that in awhile, but I miss those.
Now the Bleed is stupid. I called this out originally when I ISOed Priestess. I see in no gamestate at the time of the bleed that scum would purposefully bleed Priestess if they thought she was town, because realistically up to that point there wasnt uch towniess there. The best answer I have seen is lolwolves from Ici and cult trying to pull heals off TLs like FK that you proposed. These are the only cases that make sense to me if the bleed is real. Geyde/Geydes team would never put out that bleed it would be extremely obvious and be like why arent we lynching Geyde. But Geydes not stupid he would never let that happen. The only other answer is Priestess is lying about the bleed, she has lied about claims as both allignments so I dnt see why she wouldn’t fake a bleed as both allignments. SO if we think about this if she was town and fake the bleed, it might be because shes a PR that wants protection. If shes scum and faking a bleed its to draw healers. It sucks that in FM healers and Healees arent informed wether a heal was succesful so we cant even prove if she is lying until Day 3 in which she would be dead if no heal went through.
