Yes, but we need to consider optimal conversion criteria. D1 there was a very real possibility he was mastermind based on the outting of royal blood. Is this a good conversion candidate?
Not digging Arete tbh. It’s kinda gut plus some of the things they’ve said.
First off, you were really prominent on thei lynch and you just change you kind like this, can you give more reasoning as to why?
I’ve noticed they’ve kept saying like “I’m not good at reading people, I’m new.” This is scummy because they can just bounce back on it. Like if he pushes a bad target, he can just use it as a crutch. Scummy.
[quote=“Arete, post:225, topic:77327”]I’m still learning how to read people.
[/quote]
This comment hit me the wrong way. It’s like he isn’t taking a solvy approach a towny would, just assuming he’s given up scum.
I also don’t like how everyone immediately townread him for just posting a couple reads. Scum can do that, easily, especially if they’ve played the game before.
Maybe it’s just be being paranoid, but I don’t really like it, especially if Cheeki ever flips town.
it’s amazing this was typed out on a phone
I’m not sure if there ever was a specific focus on them.
They’ve played Throne of Lies, an ultra turbo game where mechanics are actually the most important thing.
We had discussed the lynch extensively in Imperial Chat, which is why I initially thought it was the right option. However, Geyde made a fair point that unless one of the inactives were the second groupscum (which was the Imperial Chat best guess for what Cheeki was), it was surprising that there was nearly no counterwagon (apart from two votes on Andrej, one of whom was coming from one of my strong townreads), since scum will usually push a counterwagon if one of them is on the stand.
I chose Andrej over any of the other possibilities for where to put my vote because, as I said, I’m trying to put pressure on the inactives, and since Andrej was the only inactive with votes on them, they were the one where I thought I had the best chance of successfully applying pressure.
I know for sure 2 people are in the librarian chat from day 1, arete and waz.
Still yet to figure out the librarian, and the two possible invitees from today.
Also, I’m about to go to dinner, I’ll probably be back sometime in the next 45 minutes to an hour, give or take.
And yeah, I’ve played ToL before but I don’t have forum match-type experience from anywhere but this forum.
I know who the Librarian is exactly, and I’m sticking guards on them.
No reason to go hunting.
Actually I’m going to wait to elaborate on this until the person posts more I want to see if they repeat the behavior more
(Incidentally, I’m back from dinner, if anyone had any more questions about the rationale behind any of my decisions.)