Ill have you know I graduated top of my class in the Marine corps.
fair. i forgot PoI was a thing. I’m about to hang out with all 3 of my irl friends. I’ll drop my logs here
N1:No action (this was captain)
N2: Crescendo Magnus
Converts that I think could’ve allowed for the kill on Sulit. Not 100 percent sure if some of the ‘guaranteed to succeed at the attack’ converts would or not.
I mean, I got that you were a Squire soft (we are also in a log network together), I didn’t actually need an Iso to pick up on that one.
I Iso’d you during N1 but I didn’t have the chance to fully Iso you again, and in any case the tell might be in someone else’s interactions.
Sulit wouldn’t be top townread though, would he? Unless they guessed incorrectly that he was Arb.
Just because you softed a class doesn’t make it impossible for you to be evil.
Like I explained earlier, your EoD is suspicious, and EoD is when scum is most likely to make mistakes because it’s when there’s the most pressure, and when they have the least chance for discussion.
Ok EoD is over and I explained why I voted, but because I voted somone that flipped HOB, wow Im scum. Not anyone else on that wagon is evil, only me. Got it. Hey can I get a wallpost of somereads on everyone, just wanna see where ur heads at
Squire claims also seems like the equivalent of Maid claims in standard FoL/ToL.
1 Like
So, here’s the readlist I had in my logs that would’ve flipped had I died. I modified my null reads a little based on night events and moved the dead people down to the bottom.
Townreads:
Maxwell: Mechanically confirmed librarian.
Possessed: Seems like basically locktown, in my opinion, based on their general solvey attitude, their repeated attempts to drive the thread motion forward, and their general attempts at logically justifying their reads, even when I disagree with them.
Geyde: Seems like a Righteous Emperor so far. Some of his choices for Imperial Nightchat feel a little odd to me, but he’s been acting quite solvey and trying to keep the thread motion going. The pointing out the lack of a counterwagon on Cheeki, then pushing the lynch anyway, was kind of weird.
Magnus: Hardclaiming doesn’t confirm you but I don’t think scum would hardclaim so early and with so little pressure on them.
Wazza: Hardclaiming still doesn’t confirm you but I don’t really see scum outing specifically to hardclaim ‘only one neut’ when that could so easily be disproven, and Fortune Teller is pretty hard to fake.
Pokemon Kid Ryan: I’m going to be honest, this is a gut read more than anything else, but PKR, despite being less active and contributive than some, still feels HoB to me.
Nullreads:
Andrej: Null read. The Arbiter was supposed to check them tonight; the fact that they’re alive is at least somewhat promising.
Kai: Null read.
JaketheWolfie: Null read, hasn’t really done much.
Bluestorm: Null read, hasn’t really done much, opening isn’t great. Might be a good Arbiter check.
Scumreads:
Lymphoma: Are we just going to ignore how they literally claimed Unseen day 1? Frankly, this reminds me a lot of his play in FoL 22, where he was a Warlock. I don’t think he’d draw nearly so much negative attention to himself if he were Cultseen/NK, but I think it’s very likely that he’s a scumneut once again. They were a little better in night chat, but I don’t want to give them a free pass for literally outing as evil.
Datbird: I still don’t like his Iso – almost all fluff, very little actually contributing content. He did in fact at some point give a readlist but other than that I’m not seeing much in the way of attempts to solve, which given his post count there should be more than zero of. I think Datbird/Andrej is a potential scumteam, given how quickly he came in at the end when it looked like Andrej might be the lynch.
[reads I had on dead people]
Sulit: Probably town. I don’t think scum would randomly draw attention to themself for no reason by pushing on the towncore, and being wrong doesn’t make you scum.
HTM: I feel like HTM is being substantially quieter than they usually are as Town, though admittedly I haven’t seen their scumgame. Still, the unusual quietness and distinct lack of effort at solving feel scummy to me. Day 2 was a bit better, but I can’t shake the feeling that they’re trying to get towncred by asking people not to hardclaim without actually contributing.
Alice literally didn’t update my logs in the network after I at-mentioned her in my class card. I’m not lying, that would be really stupid given that I’m IN A LOG NETWORK.
/vote Bluestorm
I realize that ‘OMGUS’ is viewed as suspicious, but that’s a blatantly false statement and the only explanation I can come up with is that you’re evil trying to get the towncore out. Either that or this is a terrible reaction test, but, well, I didn’t visit HTM, so.