[SFoL] SFoL 53: Looming Threat - Completed

[Wazza]

This contradicts yourself.

[Teleology]

I’m reading him as town but not disregarding that possibility if My other reads aren’t working out well

[Wazza]

Me or Italy have to be scum according to Italy themself.

[SirDerpsAlot]

You must have like stopped reading after that

[PokemonKidRyan]

Is it me or is Solic basically just open wolfing?
Putting almost no effort into this game.

It even asked if I was claiming Hunter.
Like damn I do not see this as hard

[Teleology]

I can see that. There can be a theory that implies one of you is scum. It basically entails that Italy is either lying about Arcane empowering you and trying to frame you over Luxy’s death and used the Sage day ability to redirect Luxy’s jail target… or he is real court Wizard and empowered you and you didn’t TW Luxy and Luxy died

[Teleology]

But that discounts the possibility that scum had a strongman to kill Luxy with and that they probably knew he was Prince based on everyone hinting toward it >>

[Vulgard]

Solic’s recent posts have felt like he was frozen in the thread. Basically he isn’t posting what anybody wants and is just doing his own thing in a way that feels more performative than gamesolvey.

Look at his recent posts and tell me that’s not the conclusion you’re reaching. He has been re-evaluating and re-reading the game, sure. But all of these posts have led to nothing. He brought up some points, but he doesn’t appear to be going anywhere. That’s not what he did in LotR FM as town, where he had a clear direction.

He was similar D1 actually, but there was no lynch D1, so I was willing to let that slide. So far, I have been townreading him because he appears to replicate his attitude from LotR; proud, dismissive of people scumreading him, ready to stand his ground. But the thing he doesn’t seem to be replicating is direction.

Am I the only one seeing this?

[Maxwell]

So you’re saying he seemed similar to his LotR town play initially, but under further analysis you notice that his posts are going in circles / leading nowhere?

[Maxwell]

That seems like it would be a pretty big red flag already. How is it more noticeable now than it was day 1?

[Arete]

Alright, I’m caught up now. Solic is super scummy and I’d like to request that we let him self-resolve via bleeding out or not, but given that there’s a thunderdome I’d rather resolve that.

Bearing in mind that scum knows which if any of Priest and Mystic spawned, I think Kyo is more likely to be the scum here. I wouldn’t expect Marshal to randomly claim Mystic when he knows there’s a Priest, whereas I could totally see Kyo claiming Priest when he knows there’s a Mystic.

/unvote
/vote Kyo
@Alice

[Arete]

Also, since it’ll be outed tonight anyway and I’ve seen a few people mentioning its target as a good one for night actions, Maxwell is my N1 greencheck, I’m immune to tailors including the Godfather so you all should stick him in your townpile.

[Vulgard]

I should probably start using evidence for my reads.

@Solic

I live! I’m now going to do this every day 1. Thanks for the protection. Tinfoiling that that was the reason for just 1 death this night.

What the fuck happened with Luxy though. Why did he claim ugh…

I wasn’t jailed btw, saw some confusion about that.

I caught bits and pieces of the thread while sneaking at work breaks, but I’m so out of the loop, might read from scratch.

“I’m going to fake contributions throughout the day, so I might as well say it right now. I can use the argument ‘my thought process has been transparent’ if I set it up like this.”

@Solic

From the first 500 posts or so I’m getting Hja TvTing with Priestess. Hja is doing their annoying continued one liner why posting that I’ve only see them do as town and Priestess is visibly frustrated at being scumread. They made many comments before that they prefer playing scum, so I don’t think they’d start ATEing to that degree.

“I might as well call Hja and Priestess/Vulgard town because I won’t be able to mislynch them.”

@Solic

I like Arete’s callout here. They are typically polite to a fault and I don’t think they would show such contained aggression towards Magnus, but either capitalize on it or leave it alone.

Don’t think they’d orchestrate that either if both scum, because it is directly insulting, so townlean. (Also Arete easily breaks down in ISOs, so will do that later)

Centuries vs Soul is giving me scum vibes on Soul. They are being overtly defensive on their noncontribution, similarly to Luigi’s mansion. Their volume is completely different here, but they have improved that in CoC.

Tele pinged me also here with making very strong reads early on that don’t feel so deserved and also LAMIST posts.

“I will put forth a ton of reads without followup, because I want to see who I can mislynch among these people.”

@Solic

This readlist is super terrible and you have good reason for hiding it. You don’t post a town only list, when you should be scumhunting.

@Solic

The hypocrisy is noteworthy. I feel like I completely skimmed over Kyo thus far.

“I might as well shade Kyo and Marshal while I’m at it! I’m not really trying to lynch them, but I’m totally reading them and pointing out what I find scummy. Yeah!”

@Solic

/vote JGoes

…What?

@Solic

They never answered me on this.

That was the only thing Solic said about Jgoes today prior to his vote on Jgoes. Was he really going in the direction of ‘Jgoes scum I want to lynch him?’ I guess I could buy this being a pressure vote, but he has been calling a lot of other people scum. He even had more reasons to call Marshal scum than Jgoes.

@Solic

And this is a very unsatisfactory answer too. Why would you shade him like that then? grrr.

@Solic

This readlist is super terrible and you have good reason for hiding it. You don’t post a town only list, when you should be scumhunting.

This is about Marshal. Later, he says:

@Solic

What’s the case for Marshal being top wagon?

So is he townreading Marshal or not? First he finds reasons for Marshal being scummy, then townreads him. The thought process feels a little unnatural. “I find Marshal scummy. Wait, why is the person I find scummy being voted? I have no idea why he’s being voted.” <- This doesn’t make much sense to me.

@Solic

Because JGoes is 90% scum to me. ^^

Based on Solic’s earlier posts, there were like 5 other people he could have reasonably voted. Yet now he says ‘Jgoes 90% scum.’ Based on what? Because he didn’t answer Solic’s question?

@Solic

Still need to update it.

1. Magnus - Townlean
2. Frostwolf103 - Hasn’t posted
3. KyoDaz - Hasn’t posted
4. Italy - Light Scumlean
5. WazzaAzza - Scumlean
6. Ozzkozz - Hasn’t posted
7. Luxy
8. Jakethewolfie - Hasn’t posted
9. Cheeki - Hasn’t posted
10. Jgoesgaming - Scumlean
11. Sulit - Scumlean Compare Paint and last town game
12. Solic
13. H_Hja - Townread
14. Maxwell - Light townlean
15. Priestess - Townlean
16. SirDerpsAlot
17. Marshall - Scumlean
18. Arete - Townlean
19. Soulshade55er - Scumlean
20. Shurian
21. Teleology - Scumlean
22. PoisonedSquid - Null
23. PokemonKidRyan - Scumlean
24. Centuries - Good opening, check scumgame still.
25. Geyde

He leaves the thread with an outdated readlist and a vote on Jgoes. This is one of the main factors that makes me call him frozen. If he’s town, what is he even doing?

[Maxwell]

Wish you hadn’t outed this but it’s too late now.
With this and with the information I had already revealed about my class earlier, I am probably imminently dead.

[Emilia]

Why would kyo cc

[Marshal]

Thank you, arete.

[Marshal]

To get a ML on me and out as Lw

[Marshal]

I’ve said this thrice

[Maxwell]

a 1 for 1 is completely not worth it this early no matter how you slice it

[Wazza]

@Teleology

he is real court Wizard and empowered you and you didn’t TW Luxy and Luxy died

I definitely did TW Luxy.

Sooooooo…