Yes, the fact that heās assuming that it works the opposite way it would normally work in an SFoL, and assumes that for no reason, is really setting off my scumdar.
(obvious exception is obvious but I have a kind of angleshooty reason why I donāt think that applies, which Iām not explaining because I donāt want to angleshoot)
I really need to see the analysis of why Luxy is off from Pkr to have an idea of Pkrās side.
I am confident that Luxy is town based off of what theyāve posted so far. He has conviction in his pushes in a way that he just canāt pull off as scum.
My personal take on the initial debacle regarding the bleed is that it devolved too quickly into accusations for thread direction at that point to not be predominantly controlled by town
Itās like how people reacted in SFoL 49 when FK gladiated themselves. Thread went wild and the wildest were town.
A bit different of an example but I think it still holds here
PKR and I have mindmelded quite a bit with that so his point of view comes from town or heās trying to pocket me but I donāt think he would claim Hunter as scum
To elaborate on this:
-Sheās doing a specific buddying/whiteknighting thing where she intentionally draws associations with a townie to make them look suspicious (sheās done that in previous scumgames, and discussed the fact that sheās done that)
-Sheās also doing a specific pocket-y thing with likes, or was earlier; I compared her meta from previous games and as far as I can tell itās a weirdly accurate scumtell for her (you can compare her use of likes in FoL 22 and EFoL 3 to see this pretty easily)
-Sheās misunderstanding things to a far greater degree than is plausible for her to do by accident (I explained this one earlier)
Iām not scumreading her because of the OMGUSing or for claiming scum, because both of those are NAIish for her.
There were a couple of posts that pinged me earlier as trying to get the Prince/Justiciar to slip up and out themself but those are unfortunately also NAI.
I do believe in thinking the same thing does mean a common occurance is in play; however I do not believe itās primarily alignment-based.
It may be class-type based or other things.