Back now from an exam
I’m trying to say that I think Pkr is bad because when he was forced into admitting his bleed, his argument was so bad that it had to be overcompensating for something (namely, the fact that Luxy is heavily townread)
I know he was heavily softing it
I don’t care that he was heavily softing it
i’ve missed at least half the thread so my reads are probably outdated
I’m townreading you, Geyde, {Priestess given Solic flips scum, and I’m confident there’s no more than one scum between them}, Luxy, Soul, and Hja, and townleaning several other people, and I only have a couple outright scumreads at this point. (List may be incomplete because I can’t fit the text box on the same screen as the player list, so I probably forgot some people).
i’ll try
I just don’t think he’d have claimed it at all if he were scum who bled Luxy. The soft matters because it shows he wasn’t forced into admitting it, he basically did so on his own.
I mean in the context of his explanation
He was forced to out his reasoning after Solic outed his softs to thread
- Magnus
- Frostwolf103
- KyoDaz — town lean / isn’t sheeping, minmelds with me a lot
- Italy — town lean — CW — / blatantly not in his scum meta
- WazzaAzza — null / posts have been NAI imo
- Ozzkozz — null (neut?) / different entrance, either neut or I can’t read him yet
- Luxy [Bled D1] — null / entrance was inconsistent with my town meta vibe and read on him, but afterward his flow of logic seems to make sense
- Jakethewolfie — town lean / in his town meta
- Cheeki
- Jgoesgaming — slight scum / contributions look bad
- Sulit — town
- Solic — null / I don’t know how to take his “make me king” “protect me” plays
- H_Hja — town lean / in her town meta
- Maxwell — null (evil neut?) / has been saying suspicious things, “idgaf” mindset
- Priestess — Butler — town lean / Stubborn and pure
- SirDerpsAlot — slight town / lazy town, posts aren’t as deliberate as I would expect them to be if he were scum
- Marshal — slight scum / Feels more like the Marshal from LOTRFM
- Arete — scum lean / asking a lot of questions without providing much substance of their own, SRing Priestess despite how they should know her meta and be protecting her (Arete admitted to me that they would have defended me in LOTRFM had they been town)
- Soulshade55er — slight town / actually posted D1, I liked the beginning posts
- Shurian — town lean / very pure and genuine, tries to get people involved
- Teleology — Me
- PoisonedSquid
- PokemonKidRyan — slight town — Hunter or “Club” Leader / softed a bleed on Luxy D1
- Centuries — town lean / acts the same as the town game I played with him. Goes aggro on people to get reads from them.
- Geyde — slight town / helpful and productive
That’s 11/25 that could be scum in my mind. I count null reads as potential scum but yeah
Excessive town reads = scum that can’t find people scummy enough to throw shade onto?
I mean I have a lot of nullreads but if most of the scum are in my nullreads it means that the scum basically aren’t trying to do anything in the thread at all.
Why does this list feel like “too many townreads”… most possible not-towns are basically afk
Towncred or WiFoM
Scum have no reason not to set flags for their claims in order to clear themselves
It’s the same reason that Wazza hardsofted investigative d2 in SFoL 52 when the correct play for him would be to just not out as he would then have to give information on several players