[SFoL] SFoL 53: Looming Threat - Completed

Forum Matches Completed
#6384

You aren’t justiciar, damn it.

1 Like
#6385

Well if this is all true I am a bit depressed tbh

#6386

Oh, thanks, I somehow missed that.

#6387

I thought everything was lining up and now that I was probably completely wrong about everything I am just pretty sad about it

#6388

Can you remind me what your previous scumreads were? And townreads?
I’m at a point when I’m trying to make sense of the threadstate.

#6389

@Teleology is who I meant to respond to. I didn’t even respond to the post properly. Smh.

#6390

@Arete Thoughts on SirDerpsAlot.

I believe he’s rolled scum this game.

#6391

This was last night:

  1. Magnus — If Arete is scum Magnus is town (Arete said Magnus was scum both times when asked)
  2. Frostwolf103 — slight town
  3. KyoDaz — town lean / isn’t sheeping, mindmelds with me a lot
  4. Italy — town lean — CW — / blatantly not in his scum meta
  5. WazzaAzza — town lean — chrono
  6. Ozzkozz — null (neut?) / different entrance, either neut or I can’t read him yet
  7. Luxy [Bled D1] — Town lean
  8. Jakethewolfie — town lean / in his town meta
  9. Cheeki
  10. Jgoesgaming — slight scum / contributions look bad / If Arete is scum J is scum (Distancing)
  11. Sulit — town lean
  12. Solic — slight town by association
  13. H_Hja — town lean / in her town meta
  14. Maxwell — slight scum / I feel like he hasn’t contributed as much as he should and I know he’s a good player
  15. Priestess Vulgard — Not Butler — null / Independently I am TRing her, but I believe that it might be possible she is scum with Arete. I would like to analyze her slot again after we see what Arete flips.
  16. SirDerpsAlot — slight town / lazy town, posts aren’t as deliberate as I would expect them to be if he were scum
  17. Marshal — slight town / found that there is no conversion based on class
  18. Arete — scum lean / asking a lot of questions without providing much substance of their own, SRing Priestess despite how they should know her meta and be protecting her (Arete admitted to me that they would have defended me in LOTRFM had they been town)
  19. Soulshade55er — slight town / actually posted D1, I liked the beginning posts
  20. Shurian — town lean / very pure and genuine, tries to get people involved
  21. Teleology — Me
  22. PoisonedSquid — slight scum
  23. PokemonKidRyan — slight town — Hunter or “Club” Leader / softed a bleed on Luxy D1
  24. Centuries — slight town / acts the same as the town game I played with him. Goes aggro on people to get reads from them.
  25. Geyde — slight scum / association, and gut intuition that scum are leading the court, not scummy on an individual level.
#6392

Also can we still refer to the scum as My Little Pony?
It’s much more fitting for them.

#6393

…I agree with almost all of these.
I have a theory. Either we really were completely wrong or we are allowing ourselves to be misled.
I have a potential explanation for this but I don’t want to post it now. Again, this is something best saved for post-game.
Anyway. Maybe establishing a PoE would be good. Especially if the scumteam is larger than three members.
I have plenty of people I consider strong town, so maybe we could go from there.

1 Like
#6394

Only thing I changed was that I crossed Priestess’ name for Vul’s so that I had it on my list to make edits later

#6395

The thing is, I still think the same three people are scum. Nothing changed.
That’s why I still want to flip one of Arete/Maxwell/Geyde. If the flip is town, I will be forced to reevaluate everything.
…Then again, I’m not sure if that’s a good thing either. If I need to reevaluate everything, I’m going to feel like trash.

#6396

Meta-read suggests he’s town but I’d want to take a closer look (and ideally a read that isn’t just meta).

#6397

Another thing is that I’m really self-centered this game, huh.
Sigh.

#6398

Changes since then is that I’m willing to make Vul’s slot slight town and I’m willing to make PKR/Wazza’s slots null and obviously if Arete is proven Justicar then they will be confirmed town essentially

#6399

I’ve noticed you’re hesitant to clear people. Is there a specific reason for that?

#6400

Pretty sure Priestess’s frustration and confusion about Luxy jailing himself spews that slot as town, it didn’t feel fake to me.

1 Like
#6401

Honestly? I just hate the fact that on the first day of LOTRFM all of my reads were wrong (except the scum read on you and Kai, heh) and that I had labeled scum as “town lean” like “town lean” means that I have written them off as scum basically. That’s a terrible thing for scum to be town leaned. That’s why I’ve started changing people’s positions from slight town / null / slight scum

#6402

Makes it so that I feel more flexible and open to change for interpretations of that slot

#6403

I was referring to the fact you don’t have anyone labeled as ‘town’ or ‘scum’, it’s always ‘slight town’ or ‘slight scum.’
But I suppose what you said answers that question as well.

1 Like