I am not trying to be hero either, this is suppose to be teamwork effort.
I donât know, like I said my reads have been crap this game. I would say in someone clear with influence in the thread
I have done squat and when I get the chance to do my part everyone goes âSorry, you arenât towny enough for thatâ
Magnus
I canât say much about this slot until I see more from Magnus, but this is null for me. There is towny potential, but I havenât seen much from Magnus.
N.1
I put this a light town read, as they have been making reads, trying to keep the thread on track, and their tone is decent. N.1 feels like BotF III N.1 and in my opinion thatâs a good thing.
Whysper
I hate this slot. Whypserâs opener was just awful and I feel their later posts donât really improve. I also think some of their reads have some of the worst progression I have ever seen. I also hate the use of mostly formal statements and emojis, but the emojis are probably more of a me thing. These posts feel fake and I just donât like them, their progression is very off, and I think some of their statements seem like code. I will obviously case this one a bit more later, but this is my highest current scum read.
Italy
Italy is actual trying here, which scum Italy doesnât do. I think Italy is likely town and thatâs mostly what I have to say regarding this slot. I could go on about this and that, but scum Italy doesnât have this much energy.
Ash
In my last game with Ash I thought they were odd, but I think they are town here. I feel like a broken record, but they are solving, have good tone, and arenât posting tons of fluff. They also seem to have independent reads, which is great. I would say this is town, but not lock town. They shouldnât be executed today though
Chloe -> Sulit
Chloe: The case on Chloe from Vulgard is very good.I remember in FoL 29 Chloe was hard pushing Vulgard and that continued in allies, but I donât see that here. I want to re-ISO Chloe in BfA 2 now (and likely will) to compare it, but it does look similar from my memory. I honestly think Chloeâs slot could be a wolf here, as there are no hard pushes from this slot and itâs mostly just questions. I donât know what else could be said, but this is likely a wolf. I wonât make a conclusion until looking at Sulit though
Sulit: Sulit hasnât made any posts that have made me think that this slot isnât a wolf, but I think Sulit should have a chance to prove herself. I like that she did disagree with Chloeâs original read and I think she could clear the slots name, but the slot shouldnât live to d3 if she doesnât improve
Conclusion: I still think that this slot is likely a wolf, but we should know that by d2 and by d3 if she doesnât improve she needs to die
Derps
I honestly think Derps is town. This wonât be contrarian, but I donât care. Derps feels like his town self. Non of the above towny things really applies to Derps and itâs mostly tone. We have hydraâd together twice and I am decent at reading derps, so I am so confident in this read, but I do want to see Derps explaining their reads more.
Zone
I donât know how I 100% feel about Zone, but I would say Zone is kind of leaning town for me (itâs not a strong tl). Zoneâs tone is always agressive, so I wonât try to read Zone on that, but I have noticed that Zone hasnât been death tunneling anyone d1. In Homestuck I recall scum Zone deathtunneling Leafia, but I donât see that here. This may be a bad way to clear Zone, but I am sticking with it, as I havenât had much problem reading Zone before.
Wazza
I will say that I wasnât seeing too much out of the norm for town Wazza, until I saw Wazzaâs EoD. Wazza doesnât make a read on Insanity at all and just comes up at the EoD and says âInsanity is likely town, letâs please lynch somewhere elseâ. I honestly donât know if Wazza does buddy/buddy stuff like that with lesser skilled wolves, but I want an explanation regardless or I will support a lynch here.
Frost
I will admit that I donât know how to read Frost super well, but I donât think that Frost is 100% a wolf. For starters Arete has said that Frost can be activity read, but I wonât rely on that alone. I will have to read cases on this slot, but I havenât seen anything overly scummy in my opinion. I will say this is PoE for me, but there are others I would execute before Frost.
Light
I put this as a light townlean (no pun intended). To explain things better, I think they have been asking good questions, solving, and such. Some people have been sidelining, but I donât think this is the case with Light. The way they handled EoD1 is also pretty good in my opinion.
these are all of my reads on the people alive. I have been working on this over the last week or so, which is why I get so upset when people go on about how I am likely scum and that I havenât done anything
1 Like
marauders donât lose gulit if they kill someone with counter. judging by the wording
I will say that I had mole at having scum equity and not being BD, I posted my TBE thing earlier, and I said that CRich is likely town in more or less words
yep, they should counter, you will die. but hey it clears you and one of the marauders from convert
Youâd think it was a bad idea regardless of alignment so this tells me nothing about your alignment. If you donât want to be nightvigged, start trying to convince us that youâre town.
I donât think we can ever be 100% certain until he flips.
Those pesky dragons. Always breathing fire everywhere.
Same here. I can definitely see Whysper being the convert.
I agree. N.1 is towncore in my eyes now and admittedly, Gorta is looking better too.
Weâll have to try smarter, not harder.
These are my thoughts too. So we need to look for someone acting different than they did D1 and D2.
As of right now, I think Iâm willing enough to risk Gorta being scum to agree to this. I want to hear what Alice thinks first though.
On second thought, same allies as last night.
I think youâre already out of the PoE of most players with being okay with dying like this.
The visionary canât be detected with a check.[quote=âAlice, post:7208, topic:83266â]
Iâm technically suspecting you of being the convert because of you straight-to-the bat convert hunting instead of trying to find the starting wolves. I donât think youâd genuinely hunt for the convert right after it happened over starting scum.
[/quote]
I can honestly see t!Vulgard doing that. I donât know if w!Vulgard would though.
I can agree with this though.[quote=âAlice, post:7224, topic:83266, full:trueâ]
If youâre legit, then N.
[/quote]
N.1 will be dying anyway.[quote=âAlice, post:7253, topic:83266, full:trueâ]
I think gortaâs just the Visionary here.
His reaction to being put in the PoE when wolves are close to loosing look more like a wolfâs reaction than a villagerâs one.
[/quote]
Itâs a possibility, even if Iâm starting to think he might be town.
A visionary that knew that at least one town killer was going to shoot him.
How is that a good idea? Heâll just die to our counterattack. That and Iâm really starting to think Gorta is town here. I canât say for sure though.
actually to be more specific, shoot leafia since no sane person would convert a D2 bled (Wazza).
AT, thatâs the worst idea possible and never comes from a good king. Gorta will just die then.
I am just pissed off because everyone SRs me still for being inactive/quiet most of the time and not doing much. This isnât my first 5 games here, so most of the people here should know how I play.
For what itâs worth, I donât think youâre scum any more. As to who youâd shoot, Iâm not sure yet. Actually, Gorta is a good pick for allies I think. Along with me and Alice.we need to plan things out about who Gorta will be shooting.
look, gorta is probably the most sus person(beside mole) alive atm. If he is visionary, he wonât shoot and gorta would be alive thus confirming him as visionary. If he does, he dies and nobody lose anything to gulit