Long story short: This behavior is normal for Surge IMO.
I don’t expect anything good coming from that slot at all.
You talk about me losing credibility for spitevoting, while you yourself lose credibility for voting someone whom you vote for no other reason than ‘I think he is scum’…
Do you see how hypocritical this is?
That’s not what I read though. Are you sure you’re not just either lying about Alice to make her look bad, or simply outright ignoring her reasoning?
Villagers don’t think like this and their thoughts generally have more grey areas. I’m pretty sure those thoughts were fake which is why I think Insanity has a fairly high chance of being a wolf here.
Welp. I’m about to evaluate his response, so…
“This ought to be fun.” (Sarcasm)
Coincidence how your top 2 scumreads and the 2 players you want lynched want you lynched.
It’s less a coincidence and more of a “OH MY GOD, YOU SUCK” kind of response though.
Obviously, I won’t agree on the read of Alice/Surge being on the Town read, same with Leafia being on the scum read.
But I failed to see on why is PKR on your “to-kill” list, same with Wazza but on scum read.
And I believe that Whysper is definitely somewhere in the town read.
Conclusion: Mostly agree.
But anyway, on the topics of Surge, I could see him being TWTBAW, but him acting like that is just, welp, bad.
…interesting. I was actually pointing out to the fact that I also have a lot of townreads, and I wanted to see whether you wanted to point out any sort of criticism to that since you did the same with Alice when you initially misunderstood her readslist, but I guess you didn’t give me any.
PKR’s circumstances is a meta-thing. You’d understand if you read my interaction with Wazza.
My scumread on Wazza was explained in P#914.
I don’t see enough reason to put Whysper on my townreads yet though.
–other than her not scumslipping (yet), that is.