Yes, I gave the explanation during the time when I originally voted for Surge. So when it became plausible that Surge might be Poacher, I thought it better to switch to Insanity since he was 2nd in line.
Iāll post my previous explanation here too since it seems to get missed/overlooked. Haha. 
Haha, itās actually more like I just got busy again. 
But going through some posts now. I replied to some other posts about my explanation on Insanity. I can copy it here if you miss it from all those as well.
I lean towards Leafia, especially since she claims to have something important to contribute based on her class. You can find out for sure whatās up with that.
its very ācommentary-yā
if you said āI think this is wolfyā or some form of suspicion onto them, even if you dont SR them, some sort of thought on how you perceive the post instead of marking something as ānoteworthyā id accept this as a fine answer
but you never note what this is āevidenceā for, or show leaning into the direction.
/vote gorta
meant to be here
nothing there has pinged me as villagery; mech talk, questions, etc, which arent necessarily scummy but he doesnt seem have pushed reads/make alot of them
take this
but then I didnt see his take on leafia, despite this somewhat looking like they disagree
also I think him specifically saying HoB here points to them being specifically HoB
I get that reading this absurdly long thread is difficult but there is ground to work on and I dont see anything
Yes, I recall seeing a post afterwards from Alice with similar thinking and that helped confirm my thoughts.
I have been sleeping, preparing things to get a job, and eating. I am back now and plan to make reads and such
I havenāt even begun to try and solve yet for the reasons stated above, but I am here now
I never said I agree or disagree, but due to the nature of the thread I have had to skim it to keep up with the game. I have missed some things likely and I want to know why you townread Leafia. I have my suspicions about Leafia, but I havenāt made a confident read there yet. I only asked that to figure out why you believe what you said
Haha, and I actually find this reasoning substantially lacking. Just moving your vote to put pressure here? You try to claim that I only had wolf vibes, yet your reasoning isnāt even that. Just no response to read questions, so he becomes top scum? So even though I agree with your vote on Insanity, Iām kind of wondering why. Will you perhaps be changing it later for the person you really want?
There is no response towards the pressure, so I kept my vote until there is someone more scummy than him or he post something towny.
Iām eager to see this to help get a better read on you. I just hope it doesnāt come too late. Iāve been going back and forth on what to do. Iām truly hoping we have a king on our town side.
Magnus
I canāt say much about this slot until I see more from Magnus, but this is null for me. There is towny potential, but I havenāt seen much from Magnus.
Cheese
I really donāt like this slot. Cloned has been on the sidelines, posted mostly fluff, and I donāt see many villagery posts from the slot. This is a light scum read, but this is a slot that has a chance to bounce back in my opinion. The thing I donāt like the most is that Cheese is coasting and seems like he doesnāt care.
N.1
I put this a light town read, as they have been making reads, trying to keep the thread on track, and their tone is decent. N.1 feels like BotF III N.1 and in my opinion thatās a good thing. I donāt know what else to say
Insanity
Insanityās ISO is just tunnel Alice the ISO. I wish they would really branch out and do more non Alice/Chloe stuff. Like I feel like it would be easier to read them if they werenāt just tunneling Alice. My one hangup is does scum go after Alice d1? Itās usually easier to kill or convert Alice to either silence her for good or get her to your side. I put this one a null, but I donāt know if this is trending scum or town. Can anyone help me out here?
I will do more later, but this is a sample
The final post will have a full town to wolf scale as well and will be a full read list
1 Like
ISO on Centuries, as his slot has been bugging me. Conclusion: Light townlean, a decent bit of content and none of his interactions seemed to be too awkward. I'd like to see some more fleshed out reads, but otherwise this slot is looking good.
Started off as a random vote, evolved based on reactions, which I like.
Doesnāt really take a stance here, but still a post I like nonetheless.
I like the early reads, and he also basically just left out the no-posters which is actually a good look imo because it means he actually at the very least looked through the posters
I donāt really like this response to Sethās question, although it was a stupid question. This whole interaction between Centuries and Surge is just odd all over.
I donāt really remember the context, but this feels more like he was just trying to slap a read on us. I think I was just saying that SDA is an idiot
New take on Leafia, I like it, and it definitely fits with what Leafia had been doing up to that point, and I like the fact that his reads werenāt stagnating.
I would like to hear what your thoughts on gorta are now. I know not too much has changed, but Iād still like to hear it.
I would definitely like to hear your case on Frost and Ash, if they are still high PoE for you. Frost, I didnāt like, but thatās just because something felt off with a couple of his posts. Overall, his content has been decent.