SFoL13: Pestilence (BD & Alchemist Win!)

Forum Matches Forum of Lies
#1322

You voting me literally makes you even less worth of any trust

#1323

You have no reason to NOT give a full case immediately if you’re not going to vote with the others, too.

#1324

Except the speed of writing and/or having stuff to do :wink:

1 Like
#1325

Then he should’ve voted me alongside his case instead of before it

#1326

I can assure you, I am no professional. Playstyle differs like anti-neutral stance and other things

1 Like
#1327

Build a convincing case while I’m alseep. If you’ve managed to convince me to swap off cheese by then, I will. (Hopefully cheese claims while I’m asleep.)

@ Wolfy and Vulgard.
There isn’t anything Ici has said that makes me think he is scum. I’m not trying to hard defend him, but if we REALLY believe he’s a problem, the prince can jail and exe him. I say we hear out anything he says and his reads for now.

@Icibalus I’d appreciate a fully updated list of your reads sometime in the next 8 hours if you don’t mind. I encourage anyone who hasn’t given a town circle yet to do so as well.

#1328

Also, if we have a hunter, they can wolf him to prove he is an alchemist. (Since he is immune to bleeding.)

#1329

Once again, I know that’s thinking mechanically, but whatever.

#1330

And if he happens to be the carrier? Then you fucked the Prince over with that suggestion. It’s either a night kill if possible or Prince has to execute

#1331

Prince doesn’t visit his jail target does he?

#1332

He DOESNT want people to visit him. He’s been asking for people to not this entire game. I haven’t read him as anything even close to carrier. If anything, he’s fool/scorned/nk. I don’t think he’s cult here either.

#1333

PR-fishing dosen’t help BD one bit. The more classes scum know the more convert options they have.

Hahhahahahahhahahahahahahhaha
no

This feels to me like he’s trying to look like he’s contributing while he isn’t.

-Says he thinks all those D1 claims are a bad idea
-Proceeds to VFC
-:thinking:

‘doing nothing wrong’ is a bad defense in any case but this feels so much like he’s trying to answer my question without actually answering it.

This is either completely awful BD play or awful NK play.
Wanting to lynch a neutral is a safe scum wagon, and dosen’t reflect badly on the people who pushed it.

Also their tone has been scummy as hell anyway. I can’t fully articulate it, but they simply don’t feel like BD

1 Like
#1334

Spiritualist and Revenant are not in play
Fool and Masochist are not in play

^this is important in Ici’s case

#1335

This is why i think he could be the Carrier. He wishes not people to visit so they contract the plague, unless he is bsing us…

I would rather not let an investigative check him though

Marl, trust me on this read

#1336

@Wolfy Think from my perspective.

Give me a reason why my actions don’t make sense as a class that has the sole goal of surviving.
I only don’t want to be visited so I don’t catch the plague.

#1337

Wouldn’t the carrier love to have everyone visit them so they die of the plague?

#1338

OBJECTION!!!

Carriers win condition is to also survive the game!

#1339

He doesn;t want everyone to die. He can win with anyone providing he stays alive

#1340

But as Marl has stated, I’d want everyone to visit me so the game is over quicker

#1341

Alright. You’ve built a good case.

Vulgard, do you mind claiming so I don’t have to make my use of finger a waste?