I can explain them if you want me to
1 Like
You also said youād look into Seth and re-read 61.
Iām still a bit on the fence with him to be honest, that TgC literally wasted the day for us ā but itās nothing new when coming to Seth. Still, the fact that his activity went down is a thing.
Care to talk about this?
1 Like
This sounds rude, but I do think we put less experienced/solvey towny players in bubble - in the offchance Arete explodes and we lose them, we still have some strong players left alive.
It would be nice if
Arete
like
didnt explode tho
2 Likes
So long as Arete works with us, protectives absolutely should have them in their protection pool.
Thatās not even a discussion.
But yeah, among those two Iād probably vote for PK since:
I do want to hear everyone elseās opinion as well.
1 Like
Iām fine with being in the dream sphere;
3/4 of my abilities are niche, the other one is just Vig but delayed.
Ok dokey
Ans - Good tone, asking a lot of questions. Doing very well to contribute to the thread while barely getting sidetracked. Somehow has non-majority null reads, which might not matter, but like I guess having an opinion right now seems towny.
CRich - Sorta same thing as Ans. Good tone, making a ton of reads and ISOs day 1 tho it kinda toned down, which was disappointing but like I guess everyone doesnāt have the time for that. Something else about them makes me trust them.
PK - Sounds way too newbish to ever be scum. Iād also doubt they would ever claim such a odd class for a newcomer like stargazer. Like there could be that one slight possibility scum might have helped him with the stargazer claim, but like meh
Seth - Debatableā¦ for sure. They have uhhhā¦ made some interesting decisions to say the least, but something feels wrong. I feel like theyāre way too wolfy to ever be wolf. Night 1 Allies chat kinda helps me here as wellā¦ but like we barely got anything done in the first place so maybe I shouldnāt use that
2 Likes
Iām having a really hard time coming up with a useful read list.
I have way too many town reads and way too little scum readsā¦
Could you give me all your townreads? No explanations needed of course, I just want to know
1 Like
Even putting out your TRās helps us because it still gives us information, town hunting instead of scum hunting works for a reason.
Not like many of us have a lot of SRās/contrarian takes either, this has been an issue for a while.
Ans,
Chloe,
Arete is neutral so can you even town read them?
are the really good ones
You,
EightySecond,
Wazza,
are the decent ones,
Centuries
Seth
Highway (this one is mostly because of his failure to vote)
are the slight scumleans. But very very slight.
and I feel like im forgetting a bunch of people.
Magnus died but Ans didnāt.
That makes some amount of sense.
Frosty probably didnāt absolute zero because of the WIFOM thing set up.
I know I wouldnāt if I was them.
This is, assuming we have Frosty because that is what makes most sense.
Why are we disregarding the idea of a healer? I mean like healer is garunteed so they probably healed Ans or something
Why is Wazza so high? I did say in my logs that:
And it seems like he has some sort of information now. Are you reading him purely on that?
PKR I want your thoughts from last night as well ā did you backread or anything.
- Heās like the lowest townread I have, so not āso highā
- He seems geniune in the department where he doesnāt care. (although if he gets a boost of motivation like he said happened in a previous game, thatād be really nice)
No I am not. I wasnāt even thinking about that when I put him as townread, but itās nice to know that I have more than one reason for keeping him alive.
1 Like
I think it was likely that NK was either RBd, hit an immune, hit a healed person or jailed person.
I think we have that frost thing because the bleed lasted one night.
It is possible NK chose to kill Magnus to frame it as a Frosty NK but I doubt they would waste it on that.
Surely NK would have killed you if they wanted that.
As for the fact that was the only killā¦ it is quite possible we have a cult game.
Thereās no traditional ājailā with Executioner, unless you think that they used Hasty Sentence on D2 for some reason.
And if it was Execution then weād have another person dead, since I really doubt that anyone in their mind would execute Magnus.
Also when I asked on your thoughts I meant social reads instead of mech.
Still, itās odd that there was only one death in two nights.
1 Like
