Fiddler is basically fool on steroids.
They need to see 2/3 of the votes on them or be at L1
I STILL THINK THE CONCLUSION OF
me/wazza/emilia being maybe scum is like
super lame
TRUST ME. When I claim, you will not want Arete dead
…FINE. I will wait until you claim and if your claim fails to convince me why Arete shouldn’t die, then I will tunnel you for the rest of the game afterwards. (I.e. after Arete dies.)
/unvote
Thank you Zone
Uh, Jane was in my top 5 last night.
You were in nulls.
I’ve been TRing Jane since D1 even though they’ve somewhat dropped on D3, but like I said:
Jane - Still pretty sure this is town from D1/D2. On activity: don’t think they should be read on it yet. Reeval if they continue to stay silent.
hi
I am back
damn
well who is scum then
gorta/zone/highway/ut/emilia
sounds way too lame of a poe for me
/ut
ur tr this anyway so its like
super small
Wazza getting really upset about Jane doing NKA and concluding that Wazza is more sus, because it’s implying that town is always right, is laughably disingenuous in that it completely ignores the context of Jane’s post
Zone is Zone
like
people who died at night … usually died for a reason …
wow
amazing
still think jane’s final thoughts are like
eh
i know im town
i know wazza is probably v from lolmechs unles its unseen(?)
actually
if its unseen
wazza is potentialyl scum and emilia is ???
if its cult
wazza is scum and emilia is also always scum
thats if he flips scum btwbtwbtw
Summary
I’ve already made my stance on Anstreim, I didn’t feel like I needed to make a big show on it.
Haven’t felt the need to reevaluate this read yet as we’ve only had one flip and Anstreim has still felt fairly townie. Plus the whole PK situation makes it sound like Anstreim is very unlikely to be Cult/Unseen, in which case the worst he can be is the NK?
Not too concerned with him being NK as of right now, since NK still need wolves out. I also just don’t think he’s NK, but I’m not going to pretend I’m some expert NK hunter.
Looks good for Ans.
The only candidates for “deep wolf controlling the thread” would be Anstreim/Chloe/UT, and of those three I really don’t think any are starting wolves (maybe NK?) for multiple reasons. There’s a small chance I’m misclearing UT simply because I’m treating them like a very new player, but I’m not really willing to buy into that world yet.
Looks good for Ans/Unknown.
I’d like to hear why, as I think they’re pretty likely to just be a newb villager.
Looks good for Unknown.
Kinda thinking that gortas insistence on this very contrarian read is >rand V though. A wolf here would be likely to drop this by now.
Was going to do a full gorta ISO so I could finish my read list, and I’ll probably skim the rest later to see if I have the same conclusion, but I’ve got a few more slots I want to look at deeper so I don’t want to be here all day.
Looks slightly good for Gorta.
Conclusion: I don’t think Emilia is quite as villagery as Apprentice was, most of their “good” posts are easily posts wolves can write for towncred since they’re objective posts, not subjective. GTH, I’d say Emilia is >rand V – but I think Apprentice was more villagery. I do remember seeing a few posts stating that Emilia posting this much content is a good look for them, but I’m disregarding those because I think that’s a shitty tell in terms of meta (and it didn’t seem echoed nearly as much as the metaread on Mode)
Looks slightly good for Emilia.
Actually, I’ll post the top half of my list. Gonna reconsider everybody below this, but I’m moderately confident everybody here is a villager. List is mostly ordered although the top 3 are all pretty interchangeable, and I’m not considering conversions at the moment.
PsychoKang
CRichard564
AnstreimModeShifter* (Kind of just sheeping the consensus “Mode is in their townmeta” read, because I’ll have an aneurysm otherwise. This slot is honestly still pretty wolfy, and I really wish Magnus killed it. They have since made a few posts that are likelier to come from a villager than a wolf, but I really don’t like the overall vibes they give me.)
Chloe
Wazza
JaneWilling to explain any of these if necessary confusing but I don’t think any of these takes are very spicy.
Looks good for Anstreim/CRich.
Didn’t finish it as I thought a lot of gortas points felt tunnel-visioned. Planning on rereading both gorta/UT tonight anyway, although gorta is probably just a villager at this point.
Looks good for gorta.
[I don’t scumread any of these 3 either]
UnknownTraveler (dropped off a lot)
Emilia
Centuries
Looks slightly worse for Unknown, Emilia & Centuries.
82 gives less to go off. Looks good for Anstreim, CRich & gorta, but also for Unknown to a lesser extent. Looks slightly worse for Centuries.
Doesn’t look like they actually agreed on Wazza. They do agree on Centuries, although I don’t think Centuries is scum? I guess it’s possible they’ve been trying to stay UTR or have changed their wolfgame since then. @Centuries can you link me your wolfgames? Preferably in chronological order.
can you link me your wolfgames?
mafia colosseum game
take it or leave it
no completed games otherwise
Wazza getting really upset about Jane doing NKA and concluding that Wazza is more sus, because it’s implying that town is always right, is laughably disingenuous in that it completely ignores the context of Jane’s post
Uhh…I wasn’t upset about it, I just made a joke about it and then placed my vote on him?
unless you’re willing to read 1+yo games lmao
Fiddler is basically fool on steroids.
They need to see 2/3 of the votes on them or be at L1
…in other words, as long as long as nobody has 5 votes, we are safe from the Fiddler.
–which is already hard to get anyway if you ignore the size of the wagons at EoD3.
hi
I am back
Hi. I want you dead. But Unknown is saying that he has a reason for me to let you live, so you better make everyone massclaim so I can hear that reasoning.
well who is scum then
This is literally the question that I’ve been asking myself since D2.
I think Zone’s slot is likely scum but we aren’t executing it today because of delayed vig.
gorta/zone/highway/ut/emilia
sounds way too lame of a poe for me
Doubt it’s Gorta – his thought process remained consistent and that wallpost on Unknown isn’t something that strikes me as scum trying to shade them? It mostly boiled down to “they are self-aware” and didn’t look like a serious push whatsoever.
I mean I guess he could be groupscum in vacuum because he just vanished, but I don’t fully believe in it.
Unknown/Emilia need to be re-read, but Emilia’s posts were fine. I would expect her to just sheep/focus on consensus.
Although they both didn’t really interact with a lot of people much.
Highway is probably possible, but this is literally the same situation as Blizer yesterday. Executing empty slot isn’t going to give us anything.