SFoL62 - Regal Lions - Cult and Oneiromancer Victory!

[EightySecond]

@Chloe

but it feels like theyre standing on the sidelines, and only popping in to answer meta-related questions so it looks like theyre contributing

This is exactly how I felt when I was looking at the reactions to my argument with Jane, as noted in post #1288.

@EightySecond

Pretty NAI, but I think most wolves active during this timeframe would act similarly to Arete here; as in “be quiet, be NAI, and let this happen”.

[Chloe]

yes i said that afterwards as well

that i agreed with you and noticed it too

also i just wanna say that this isnt “look at my contrarian reads” its more of “im scared of how good arete is as a player and i realize if im right im probably dead but fuck it”

[UnknownTraveler]

Hmm well I see then. But I wouldn’t exe Arete just yet. I want Arete to defend themselves first before we decided

[CRichard564]

@Chloe

also i just wanna say that this isnt “look at my contrarian reads” its more of “im scared of how good arete is as a player and i realize if im right im probably dead but fuck it”

That includes me as well if Arete is scum and my read on them is correct.
Welcome to my world.

[UnknownTraveler]

@Chloe

also i just wanna say that this isnt “look at my contrarian reads” its more of “im scared of how good arete is as a player and i realize if im right im probably dead but fuck it”

Wha— WHAT. Ok I am sorry, but let me try to understand this. You are afraid of how much skill Arete has that you would think it is better to exe him right now???
Look, I understand that good players are scary sometimes, but seriously, this seems too extreme.

[UnknownTraveler]

I think your other reasonings were fine, but this seems a little dumb.

[Chloe]

@UnknownTraveler

You are afraid of how much skill Arete has that you would think it is better to exe him right now???

No
You’re misunderstanding

Im scared to push a good player because i know they can usually get out of it
So i need to be confident
And if im right
I probably die for it

Comprendes?

[UnknownTraveler]

Ok good…
You scared me there, I thought you went crazy or something

[PokemonKidRyan]

Idk why but when I look at the Arete slot, I cannot help but read them as town.
I could be wrong but just… I can see where others have come from here and disagree in the end.

[Chloe]

Im curious as to why.

Other opinions are gouda

[Arete]

you don’t believe this read

why are you making reads that you don’t believe in

[Arete]

@Chloe

What are your takes rn?

my reads

@Arete

Jane’s posting seems decent

@Arete

I want to say it’s wolfy but I think that’s partially just PKR’s personality

@Arete

Jane feels alone in the thread

probably non-groupscum?

@Arete

Ans’s posts don’t feel like he’s suffering so he’s probably town

@Arete

everything he’s [Seth] done is anti-town but for ~meta reasons~ he’s probably town anyway

@Arete

right now it feels like he’s conflating how he feels about my play this game on general principle with his read on my alignment and it’s kind of weird

@Arete

App is probably town

the ‘please convert me ’ thing lines up with how I’ve seen him play town in previous games with conversion (such as BotF 4) and I think he would tone it down if he rolled scum since it pretty consistently makes people be like ‘wtf this is wolfy’

also the way he really wanted people to engage with his reads felt more like a townie ‘please listen to me’ sort of thing than a scummy ‘please help me push this miselim’ sort of thing

@Arete

82 feels like

mrrrr

their posts feel like they’re doing things

but the actual read density in said posts is really low (lower than I remembered it as being)

I don’t really know how to explain what I’m saying

@Arete

101 feels townie although I think part of it is that use of threadreads always feels townie to me

they did also have a couple of posts that I thought were individually villagery

@Arete

my biggest hangup with UT at the moment is the fact that they think that people should be scumreading them

in my experience that sort of thing is >rand scum because townies generally don’t think they’re being scummy at any given point in time (obviously there are some exceptions but in general ) even if they are, while scum tends to think they’re being scummy even if they aren’t

can also be a sign of scum poorly trying to look town

other than that their Iso is basically fine from what I remember

@Arete

I like how 82 is specifically trying to look at how people reacted to their discussion with Jane to read them rather than just using it to read Jane

@Arete

/vote Wazza

besides the reads in the folder … 82 is trending upwards, I felt like I mindmelded with that slot some today, and Jane has gone from ‘eh probably town I guess’ to ‘very likely town’ (although that’s partially mechanics)

also apparently I never explicitly said this but I think CRich is probably a villager (not that that’s particularly controversial )

[Arete]

@Arete

why are you making reads that you don’t believe in

this is a serious question

[EliThePsycho]

/unvote Arete

i basically just bandwagoned there to pressure them.

[Chloe]

I do believe this read lmfaoo

[CRichard564]

At worst Arete is a neutral and we need group scum and NK out, not neutrals.
/unvote

[Arete]

no you don’t

[Chloe]

@Arete

I felt like I mindmelded with that slot some today, and Jane has gone from ‘eh probably town I guess’ to ‘very likely town’ (although that’s partially mechanics)

So by this logic I’m town or trensing upwards too?

I had the same conclusion on Jane

[Chloe]

Yes

I do

It is my read
I believe in it

[EightySecond]

@Arete

you don’t believe this read

why are you making reads that you don’t believe in

Why do you think Chloe doesn’t believe in her read?

@CRichard564

At worst Arete is a neutral and we need group scum and NK out, not neutrals.
/unvote

Why are you so sure that Arete is not Unseen or Cult, and specifically not NK if they are a neutral?