SFoL62 - Regal Lions - Cult and Oneiromancer Victory!

[Chloe]

@highway_101

what macro case is there for an arete scum world

Macro confuses me

I feel like ive provided a macro case - it feels like theyre just
existing
on the sidelines
watching shit happen
and they pop in every once-in-a-while to say things that dont lead anywhere - and dont make conclusions after asking questions

[TheBlueElixir]

@Chloe

This is… the main reason I’m pushing Arete, but you don’t agree with my reasons?

boop

Other reasons I thought you were going off of

@Chloe

I find the fact that they outted having been Condemned kinda odd?

@Chloe

It seemed like fishing

@Chloe

You never put a reason for your vote
You just voted
And you never asked the question again
Someone else did

and some ‘meta bad’

admittedly I thought there was more here

[UnknownTraveler]

@TheBlueElixir

and some ‘meta bad’

The real me says meta bad. The fake me says meta bad. Conclusion: Meta bad unless on very specific people

[Chloe]

yes im going off of those too

but we agree on that one take

[highway_101]

After trying to gimmick tbe’s slot by reading the previous person:

• Math didn’t fall into the traps I would expect new scum to do (mainly regarding tmi and stilted reads)
• Extreme hedge but is justified by being new player

so, kinda nulltown

[highway_101]

How experienced is Emilia
And is their posting style normal to how they normally play?

[TheBlueElixir]

anyway

executioner has no penalty upon hitting town besides wasting time(and possibly a town’s life)

unless they were to make it to endgame, they prob wont run out of uses

…I mean, I’d actually say the executioner should ahem executionate

its rather early, yes

but I think I’d like it, with the main penalty being we lose a town if arete is town, which is a world I dont believe in enough to support it

[UnknownTraveler]

Oh wait executioner has no penalty I forgot huh

[TheBlueElixir]

point me to math’s
‘extreme hedge’ please

@highway_101

And is their posting style normal to how they normally play?

as far as I know, they havent played in months/years

[Chloe]

@TheBlueElixir

point me to math’s
‘extreme hedge’ please

its their entire ISO

[CRichard564]

Correct Executioner has no guilt here.

[UnknownTraveler]

Something about that… seems very unbalanced

[EliThePsycho]

Immoral executioner

i just had to make that joke im sorry

[highway_101]

literally everything they posted
but I’ll pull out the highlight post

@mathmods

@Jane

@mathmods

Centuries - Getting a tad aggressive on accusations against them.

Don’t like that this didn’t have a conclusion.

@Jane

@mathmods

Apprentice - Weird opener

No conclusion either

For both of these: I answered this later, but it’s mostly me jotting down what I thought about them. I didn’t reread that list so I just posted it as-is (thus forgetting the conclusions). My second list contained the actual conclusion from it (Unsure on both).

Regarding Apprentice there was too little on them, their opening post was weird, but probably NAI. Regarding Centuries, I had no idea what to think of him other than him being slightly aggressive towards the SR’s. I don’t know if that is AI for them or not so it’s just something noted and I keep an uncertain stance towards them.

@Jane

Like, King doesn’t know their teammates, so the “uninformed” part is weird?

I was referring to his unnatural wish to use the 4 players decide execution ability, not him knowing his teammates. That ability is clearly anti-town in most cases (and in the cases it’s not, how would you even know it is useful?)

@Jane

@mathmods

Highway - Weird introduction, but letting it slide. Uncertain for now.

Not sure why it differs from Apprentice then. Could you explain your reasoning here more

As I mentioned, it’s the same for Apprentice. I have to change some of my opinions now that I see there have been more posts from both of them.

[highway_101]

@Chloe

I feel like ive provided a macro case - it feels like theyre just
existing
on the sidelines
watching shit happen
and they pop in every once-in-a-while to say things that dont lead anywhere - and dont make conclusions after asking questions

why is that scum over disinterested townie
defaulting to trying to clear yourself mechanically makes sense in disinterested arete world

[TheBlueElixir]

@mathmods

PKR - Getting incensed over Seth’s provocation makes me unsure of him, but I’m leaning towards town for now.

@mathmods

Highway - Weird introduction, but letting it slide. Uncertain for now.

@mathmods

Regarding Apprentice there was too little on them, their opening post was weird, but probably NAI.

I found only 3 hedges

like

find me whats so wrong about it

(yes, I know 3 hedges in 20 posts are bad but really, its getting worked up)

---

alright

@mathmods

Regarding Apprentice there was too little on them, their opening post was weird, but probably NAI.

hedges

@mathmods

I don’t know if that is AI for them or not so it’s just something noted and I keep an uncertain stance towards them.

@mathmods

That ability is clearly anti-town in most cases (and in the cases it’s not, how would you even know it is useful?)

@mathmods

As I mentioned, it’s the same for Apprentice. I have to change some of my opinions now that I see there have been more posts from both of them.

the things you probably think are hedges but arent(besides maybe the first one)

[highway_101]

making a correction
I think math doesn’t have tmi
because lolsk

[CRichard564]

They seemed alone in thread. I ruled out Maths now TBE as group scum D1 because of that.

[TheBlueElixir]

…sk?

well we’re not NK(using ‘we’ correctly now), but ill take not TMI

---

your one of the 4 right?

it requires unanimous to hammer and thats not going to happen soon

so you can pressure vote peeps

[Chloe]

@highway_101

why is that scum over disinterested townie
defaulting to trying to clear yourself mechanically makes sense in disinterested arete world

a disinterested townie should still
try to act townie?

If you’re going to ask questions, make sure people answer them - and tell us what you get out of those questions
If you’re going to stand on the sidelines, at least pop-in with things that further threadstate, and spark conversation

But i do see your point now - I just see it as less likely