Shortnight 2: Return of the POGGERS - Day 5 [6/15] - Mafoa win, Everybody (including chloe) loses

[Centuries]

MY DUMB FRENCH BRAIN IS TOO HUGE FOR U GUYS…

right

[katze]

Ban Count

Getting Banned	Banners	Votes to be Banned
Chloe	Firekitten, Arete	2/7
Marshal	Light, Leafia	2/7
Firekitten	Chloe	1/7
Not Voting	sulit, an_gorta_pratai, WindwardAway, Grace, Centuries, Trochilidae, Mistyx, Marshal	8

This votecount sponsored by “god dammit katze forgot to set an alarm again”

Additionally, the OP has been updated.

[Leafia]

He died because you thought it would get you townread and to make Chloe look bad.

[Trochilidae]

headed out for a bit
will be back
unsure when
depends on if my brain melts or not from the ethical implications of deontology

[Centuries]

guys can i say something

you know how everyone has a homer simpson in their life

i feel like im the homer simpson of my own personal life

[Arete]

reject deontology

embrace consequentialism

[Chloe]

ok i skimmed the wallpost

i read like 3 sentences and got lazy

conroy i was looking at an evo scum world because i thought he was TMI’ing me V
that aint agenda bud

[Chloe]

@Chloe

fk came in with an agenda in mind and talks as if he expected the exact nightkill

his tone is consistent with knowing marl would die, as he doesn’t react in a way that shows any surprise, and he immediately hops to the offensive, citing marl’s take on arete/me in a way that feels preplanned

this in itself isn’t entirely AI, as sure, marl had a decent chance to be the nightkill

but theres no attempt at re-eval
no panic or any sense of ‘mrrrrrr’
no indication that he prepped for any other nightkill worlds
he comes in overconfident and smug
he’s the first person to use NKA to push a worldview which is >rand w
when marl likely died for a plethora of reasons

and yes
he has pre-made memes
this is the cherry on top

@Arete does this summarize your thoughts

[Arete]

…yes but I’m scared that you’re pocketing me?

[Chloe]

im not

i just wanna talk to you about it if that wasnt accurate

[Leafia]

I’ll change that for you. Lockscummed. No way that you’re town here.

[sulit]

Yay I’m alive

[Chloe]

i have so many things to say but im having a miniature ocd-attack and i dont know in which order i want to say things and how i want them to come out

im gunna lurk for a bit while my brain untangles

[Centuries]

guys be honest

am i dumb

[Mistyx]

this game is an absurd level of angleshooty

make reads on people’s posts not the exact position of the stars at the time they logged in

[WindwardAway]

actually Conroy’s chart is good
(me biased because I’ve done the same thing in previous games to solve lol)
I’m pretty sure it indicates that at least one wolf is being close to consensus TR’d or at the very least not consensus SR’d. (but if it’s just Grace then lol)
Leafia definitely looks TMI’d town and I kind of think Marl does, too, which means it’s even less likely that Light is scum for SRing him.
I’d be willing to put Sulit in PoE despite generally TLing her because I think my quick eval could have been wrong; I need to look through her posts again and do some more thinking on her slot.

Right now I think I want today’s PoE to have FK and Marshal in it, and then the third slot is up for debate for me.

[sulit]

Yes

[Arete]

I think if he had said ‘Arete and Chloe are probably actually W/W because Marl died’ that wouldn’t necessarily be wolfy, ‘wolves are the only ones to do NKA’ is a vast oversimplification

the thing that gets me is the meme

which I’m probably vastly overthinking

but the meme feels like he knew

[Centuries]

more words please so i feel less dumb dumb

[Centuries]

@Arete

but the meme feels like he knew

he knew that you were W/W checkmate