Shortnight 2: Return of the POGGERS - Day 5 [6/15] - Mafoa win, Everybody (including chloe) loses

[an_gorta_pratai]

but read my ISO and you will see I have made reads, it’s just I haven’t done any deep dives

[WindwardAway]

Ok, I’ll ISO you during the night as I planned to anyway

[WindwardAway]

@an_gorta_pratai

I have noted that osie’s posts are weird and in my opinion scummy and trying to slander those who scum read him

Can you give some examples of which posts by Osie you think are scummy, and explain a bit why they look scummy to you?

[an_gorta_pratai]

the thread has been very active and it has made it harder to want to go through 500-1500 posts from a person, but I have made reads based on my observations in thread. It’s also partially that I am trying out a thing I observed from astand. In which you focus more on the present and take less time taking deepdives. It has increased my activity interacting with everyone else

[WindwardAway]

@an_gorta_pratai

I still have Chloe as a scum reads, but at this point I have some doubts

And do you have any examples of posts by Chloe that make you rethink your SR on her?

[WindwardAway]

Fair enough, but if you could answer my questions with recent examples that’s good enough for me. Osie hasn’t been in the game for too long, and I assume you’ve only had doubts about Chloe’s slot recently anyway, so you could just scroll to the end of her ISO and point out what sticks out to you.

[an_gorta_pratai]

@WindwardAway

Can you give some examples of which posts by Osie you think are scummy, and explain a bit why they look scummy to you?

in my ISO
(in response to grace saying osie is wolfy)

@an_gorta_pratai

I actually agree with that, but I want to look at things tomorrow

my posts from today

@an_gorta_pratai

what I don’t like from osie is the “let’s narrow the PoE down to 3” because we just need 3 mislynches to lose , so unless you are exactly dead on we just lose. I can’t speak for Blizen or FK from osie’s PoE, but I know that I am at least a villager in that PoE.

@an_gorta_pratai

Like I’m starting to get a scum lean on osie

@an_gorta_pratai

this just sounds like agenda on osie’s part because I know my role and I am somewhat sure Blizen is town, so based on my own intuition I’m sure there is one villager outside of me in that PoE and it just takes 3 to lose, which is where the agenda comes in for me

at this point osie tried to claim I was making things up about his posts

@an_gorta_pratai

@osieorb18

Okay, I think I actually believe that Wind believed those posts when they wrote them.

We need to PoE down to 3? Okay. Centuries’ post is spammy nonsense, but I sorta want to give it props because if they’re scum, it’s some pretty excessive spammy nonsense. And I like the sulit read.

I still don’t want to seriously PoE Light or Leafia because their posts were boring.

So if Sulit isn’t a thing for toDay (which might change soon), then…

FIrekitten/Gorta/Blizer is where I’m looking at on PoE.

oh really now?

@an_gorta_pratai

I don’t like osie’s “PoE” post that featured exactly 3 people, which was later retconned into “those being osie’s scum pool”

@an_gorta_pratai

they (osie) also go “this is scum to me” and then several posts later “ok, so maybe this is towny”, which screams an attempt to test the waters

@an_gorta_pratai

I have caught light on doing this before, what he does is calls someone scummy and then later calls them town when there is no momentum and that’s what I saw from your posting

you can see the shade here as well

@an_gorta_pratai

@osieorb18

Gorta: “Osie’s saying they want to narrow the PoE down to 3”

Osie: Points out that isn’t what was said.
Gorta: “LALALA, I’m not listening, I’m going to leave the thread now, LALALA!”
Gorta: “Osie tried to narrow the PoE to 3 people, as I explained!”

and I did explain my point, your response was weird as hell as well “oh yeah, these are the ones I think are wolves” when usually the PoE is used for people you aren’t so sure about or haven’t been too towny, but you used it in the exact context of potential wolves (from your own explanation) with only 3 names. There are also only 3 wolves, so

[an_gorta_pratai]

you can view the interactions see what I am replying to

[osieorb18]

@an_gorta_pratai

I still have Chloe as a scum reads, but at this point I have some doubts, I have noted that osie’s posts are weird and in my opinion scummy and trying to slander those who scum read him, I said on d2 that Marshal was weird, but I see Chloe flipping wolf over Marshal (which is why I was pushing for Chloe to die yesterday), I have Cents as a town lean, but I do have some concerns at this point, I have said that Blizer is being very towny in my opinion, FK is a town lean to me at this moment, but I want to review that slot a bit more

:shrug: You do you.

[osieorb18]

@an_gorta_pratai

the thread has been very active and it has made it harder to want to go through 500-1500 posts from a person, but I have made reads based on my observations in thread. It’s also partially that I am trying out a thing I observed from astand. In which you focus more on the present and take less time taking deepdives. It has increased my activity interacting with everyone else

I have less than 200 posts.

[osieorb18]

@an_gorta_pratai

It’s also partially that I am trying out a thing I observed from astand.

Ah, that answers some questions.

[an_gorta_pratai]

@WindwardAway

And do you have any examples of posts by Chloe that make you rethink your SR on her?

@Chloe

conroy i dont get why you wont just vote the person you’ve scumread for the entire game up until this point

they very very likely flip wolf, and you’ve said that throughout the past 3 in-game days

you know shes a slot thats greatly in contention, and needs to be figured out
you’ve thought her a wolf for a while, up until recently when you said you’re 65% on it

like
why not vote the likely wolf
even if you get chained we can afford the ML if we get a wolf out

i dont get your thought process can you please walk me through it

@Chloe

Okay
Conroy

Ignore wind for a sec

Im genuinely trying go understand your thoughts here and find you if you’re a villager

Can you explain in detail how you came to the conclusion that sulit is only 65% wolf as the day progressed

I know you said its bc she can slank as town but i didnt see anywhere where you voiced that before

Im tryina understand

@Chloe

Okay

So
You still think its likely sulit

So if we vote sulit out today and she flips wolf
Even though its suboptimal from your pov, we can afford to elim you tomorrow, since we have (idk, osie do the math) MLs until lylo, and we have to yeet through the PoE
Which
Likely includes you

I get that you think fk is liklier wolf but like
It looks like sulit is going down today over you anyways so shrug
Whatev
You very likely live today
And we get a woof

posts like these, but looking back the last one still seems agenda-ish

[an_gorta_pratai]

how do you think I found that post about your “PoE”?

[osieorb18]

At the time I figured you were just backreading.

[Firekitten]

I’m here to bus Sulit for town credit

I’m also on the bus

[Blizer]

Beep Beep

all aboard

[WindwardAway]

Don’t vote her quite yet, I think chloe wanted to make a post

[WindwardAway]

(also I legit don’t remember when EoD is so I’m not sure if I’ll be here or not?)

[Blizer]

EoD in is like 5 hours i believe?

[Blizer]

i got my live lecture when day ends rip