Shortnight 2: Return of the POGGERS - Day 5 [6/15] - Mafoa win, Everybody (including chloe) loses

okay

can you explain why you’re clearing each of the people you’re clearing

It is not a derp clear, I would always have assumed there were 4 to begin with had I not read the OP

and I did in fact read the OP but forgot that’s why I knew there were 3

If anything you should be questioning me more for it and not less lol

Yeah hold on a second, I’m on mobile and I gotta copy my notes

well I mean

if you’re a wolf then you’d always know there are three

so the question is whether I believe that you didn’t make that up

Haaaaalf asleep

Sotired

Ama!

Im caught up buthalf the info didnt stick

I know, that’s why I said you shouldn’t derp clear me

Also yeah I lied, I didn’t have good explanations written down so I filled out the rest of it now.

Light - has seemed pretty towny so far, really don’t see him flipping wolf although I admit there’s still a small chance (but the last time I convinced myself of that, I voted him out in LyLo and we lost)

Gorta - just seems like normal Gorta and not wolf!Gorta here. Post count aside, he feels pretty laid back and towny imo. I don’t see him ever flipping wolf.

Centuries - has put a great deal of effort into solving the game and also seems genuinely invested in it. I don’t think a wolf cases people in the way he does, and I also see him reconsidering his reads in a way that looks more like town doubting themselves than a wolf trying to grab towncred “in case I’m wrong”. He could easily keep a firm scumread on Chloe and keep pushing it regardless of her alignment if he wanted an easy way out.

Trochi - when I read through Night’s slot earlier, I didn’t know what to make of it. It was a lot of fluff and I only saw her point fingers at Marl and EVO, both of whom have now flipped town. I thought it looked kind of fishy but considering she wasn’t in thread much, I reconsidered when Trochi subbed in. Trochi could go either way tonally, but the way they weren’t immediately pushing someone when they came in didn’t seem wolfy (maybe I’m just wrong on how they play as wolf, but they weren’t opportunistic and instead were waiting out people’s opinions in the thread). Their interactions with Light were ~ok from both ends; I don’t really want to read so much into it since they have their own way of reading each other. But Trochi hasn’t jumped on any of the wagons and last I saw, they voted themselves instead lol. Which is ??? but weird for a wolf to do with so many wagons available.

Leafia - literally has cased herself into locktown territory and I don’t feel any need to rescind this later. I don’t know if her reads are right, but she’s the towniest player in the game.

Blizer - I told you when I ISO’d Mist that I thought she had a greater chance of flipping town than wolf, because her progression into becoming frustrated and demotivated seemed real. Her vote on herself looked pretty wolfy, but when she said she had a better idea and unvoted I immediately townread her again. Then Blizer subbed in and pushed Chloe immediately, which I first thought was also wolfy, but by the way he presented himself in the thread I decided within a short time again that he was really just town as I initially thought the slot was. Mist was LHF for wolves, hence why I think Marshal’s call to vote her out is so AI (and Marshal and Chloe were on that wagon).

2 Likes

I know my cases on Light, Gorta and Leafia are weak but I have decent faith in those reads being correct

I’d back them up with specific quotes but not on mobile

^ click post to expand
Didnt wanna quotewhole thing

^ click to expand again


I still believe in all these reads ftr

All those quotes are already expanded for me lol

Some of them narrow down to conroy/fk/marshal

I think conroy v aorn

So narrowed to fk/marshal

Of whom marshal is more wolfy

No theyre longer than whats there

Ahh yes I just found the expand button

2 Likes

I guess i mean uhhh

Click the link to jump to the post

Sorry

brain noises: ‘what if we just have Chloe and Marshal thunderdome and vote out the other one if they flip V’

me: ‘that is literally the worst idea you’ve had all game. you realize they could technically be V/V?’

brain noises: ‘but they’re not though. also Chloe is a wolf and if everyone agrees to go along with she’ll be voted out tomorrow at the latest’

me: ‘this is why you don’t get to make the plans’

Im down :hypers:

Honestly I’m fine with voting out both of them as long as we follow through with it
But somehow I feel like voting out one is going to make people change their minds on the other

4 Likes

And I still want Marshal out first because I legit think he’s wolfier

1 Like