Should the All/Any rolelist remain?

I think maybe something like your performance as BD should be ranked separately from your performance as Unseen/Cult. As in, you are considered ‘killed’ when converted, and it is a separate game for you when you are converted

2 Likes

But that’s the same for everyone in game could be converted endgame for the lose.
Personally act like a douche in game and I’ll convert you for the lose.

2 Likes

It needs to take into account your chances of winning from conversion

You need to remember that a player who is being very helpful is also less likely to be suspected unseen and is more likely to protected by CW. This means that helping BD will STILL help you win even if you are converted. Some of my best games were of me doing just that and winning anyway. If you are converted while the unseen/cult are loosing then it is never too late for you to win. If you are converted it means both of 2 things.

A: The MM/CL is still alive

B: There is at least 2 Unseen/Cult including you

This is enough to win a game of ToL even if you had outed the MM night night before and are coming into D4. I know because I have done this myself.

The only way that this can truly screw you over is if the sheriff scouted you. All you have to do to prevent this is point out that the sheriff scouted you (even if he didn’t) and then the MM will not convert you because it would be pointless compared to converting the sheriff itself or something.

The current class-list seems to be:

  • King
  • Prince
  • MM/CL
  • Assassin/Random Cult (not Apostle)
  • Random Neutral
  • Random Neutral
  • Random BD/Neutral
  • Random BD/Neutral
  • Random BD X8

4 month old thread… XD

The way the math should be is you get points for actions done to help your current faction.

If, as knight, you CS a seeker and then are converted and find a neutral or something, you get the points for both actions

Wrong thread.

1 Like

boi

1 Like