At this point if 10 posts is part of the scum team, I’ll feel bad for them.
That’s why.
You think problems are on soemoene’s else side instead of just trying to read with less posts.
Look, Centuries is trying, maybe with very reachy logic, but they are.
You just took the attitude of “It’s useless, whoever team they are, it’s just -EV” and demotivate people.
Who is more useless then? Person who tries minimaly or person who doesn’t try at all, but demotivates others instead?
But what are these posts even for, if you’re committing to actually doing 10 posts a day then you probably have much more to do no?
and like
I don’t know, just sounds mean? I have mafia experience, you can say my reads aren’t good, which I’d understand. I’m not good at reading people but this just doesn’t make me feel anything good about your slot
It was an answer to CRichard, not you.
As per you, your reads are reachy, forced. Not in a scummy way, but in a way that in several places it just looks like you didn’t know how to justify your read so you wrote something… anything.
You can be intuit, sure, but then you shouldn’t try to force yourself to come with reasoning.
Honestly it’s more like I’ve been awake for the past 18 hours or so and I’m about to sleep but I still wanted to get that out before I sleep so people could actually talk about it since morning europe time is the time of the day where there’s no posts
And honestly yes some reads can be “forced” but I still wanted to try and say something about everyone and since I wrote them rather fast the writing style was more like “I go along the ISO if there’s anything I notice I add them there” so it can look like IIOA but honestly it’s just my pure thoughts
Vote Count
| Accused | Voters | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Napoleon | Ami | 1/9 |
| Ami | Apprentice, Leafia | 2/9 |
| Chloe | Blizer, 10_posts_daily | 2/9 |
| ModeShifter | Chuck, Centuries | 2/9 |
| Italy | CRichard564, Frankie, Chloe | 3/9 |
| Apprentice | Napoleon | 1/9 |
| oB_L1ght | Alice | 1/9 |
| Alice | ModeShifter | 1/9 |
| CRichard564 | oB_L1ght | 1/9 |
People who /jettison are golden
As much as I’m no fan of L1ght scum reading me, his perspective is most likely town here.
I don’t think he’d be pushing me the way he has as a wolf here.
He’s also doing it alone by himself, which again makes me think he is town.
Catch Up
What do you make of this? @Italy
Be honest, how much was this because I said “you weren’t doing anything with your reads”? @Apprentice
Don’t think this is inherently scummy of Ami, she had a similar attitude in FoL27 and I was able to justify a bounty and get her misjettisoned as a wolf. Pressure on this slot would still be good: @Ami when you wake up, I’m keeping an eye out for this:
I’m expecting that you’ll explain some of your reads, you made this post earlier but couldn’t elaborate due to IRL stuff I assume? When you’re free, I want some elaboration on this.
Chloe is sounding a bit better, these posts are nice. I feel that there is a sense of genuity to them - I think it fits with Chloe’s character.
ob_Light
Not a big fan of these posts tbh. Feels moreso like … wanting theatrics than actually wanting to engage in the game? idk how to explain it thats the best i can come up with
Why do you use the “fortunately or unfortunately”? Like if you believe that Alice’s push is in good faith, you should be believing it’s a TvT? Also what do you think of Alice right now?
There’s also this:
Do you believe Alice is a wolf, or not? You seem unconcerned about her push on you but yet you think that a wolf is pushing you? I want you to outline your entire thought process throughout this confrontation with Alice for me. @Aelin. Your Alice reads don’t seem consistent.
I’m keeping an eye out for this.
This sort of icks me: Why is Apprentice so high? @Chloe
Furthermore, it seems that you are prepared to sheep him.
It’s like you’re putting your utmost trust in them and even willing to reconsider Ami just based on them saying it? There is a question I want to ask about this, namely:
Did you find that Apprentice’s post here actually had something to it? Or are you just willing to re-eval Ami because Apprentice said he didn’t like her?
The Ami push was pretty decent for App but still want to see more. I want to see him give us a larger view of what he thinks about the game.
Gonna take a look at this.
https://forum.imperium42.com/t/standard-wow-bfa-v2-day-1-16-16/82340/1264?u=napoleon
It would help if you come up with a general summary and a justified conclusion along with mini-ISOs.
I did. I don’t find it to be particularly revealing, mostly because you are talking about ToS2. Justifying your plays in another game with your alignments already known doesn’t really give a lot of insight towards the current game. Like I could argue with anyone why my play was good in another game, and it would mostly come off as genuine either way because it’s a finished game.
Gonna wait on a few things before deciding on who I want to kill today.
1 Like
He’s doing it solo and if he were scum, I’d expect his scum friends to join in or tell him to tone it down as it makes him look suspicious doing so when I’ve been town read by some players here already.
I for one know you, Chloe, Alice, Centuries and Seth among the active players have me as a town read.
Would the wolves really push to have me jettisoned if I’ve been town read by the active players?
Wolf L1ght would have been told by his friends to back off on my slot and move onto an easier target such as 10 Posts, TBE or Italy if he is town. Yet that isn’t what we’re seeing here.
Alright, coming back to this:
Alice Readlist Version 1
To which I criticized for it’s awkwardness. Alice’s response was:
Which is a fair response, but this accounts for 5 people. @Alice Could you walk me through your reasoning for Alice Readlist Version 1?
As for Leafia vs Alice - I have some thoughts about that, but I want to hear Alice reply first.
“The way she is there in thread when me vs Leafia / me vs Chloe happens yet she’s keeping it quiet is also weird, also at one point I had to ask her like 3 times so she could state her opinion on me vs Leafia, it really seems like she’s avoiding conflict and letting others just do their thing without her talking about it”
What is your response to this Alice?
I haven’t changed shit.
At the time there was nothing to comment on and I just simple answered CRich.
I don’t think this necessarily has to be the case FTR. Providing controversial reads can make one appear to be uniquely analytical.