town or mafia "katze makes reads for most of these" edition
1
still pushing Y blindly; if X is really town here I really don’t believe they’d so blindly tunnel somebody without even trying to justify it, but there’s no rhyme or reason, just aggressive tunneling
if X was really [role] pushing on Y D2, why wouldn’t X cop them? and if they did, they’ve already revealed they have a greencheck…
2
just wondered if you were like me or not, since that’s the kind of thing id subtly try to hint at in a way that if i brought it up later people would be less likely to assume that i made that up on the spot in order to back off safely. but since you didn’t i’m a bit concerned this is just a pocket attempt
3
like right now this is developing into a full on scumread in my head because i just don’t see why the fuck a villager would like that readlist
im not proud of this read but it at the moment it kind of feels right?
4
im pretty sure X is wolfing already
this is actually a serious read
5
i don’t think assuming Y was killed by a town vig is unreasonable at all, because it seems to be somewhat consensus that Y was a ??? kill for wolves to make - if X is a villager why would she assume the kill was by a wolf vig? like, if she’s a wolf you’re probably right here but you’re disregarding the villager perspective here
like, this entire case can easily just be explained by “X is a villager who believes Y was killed by a town vig”
ironically i think the fact that Z basically suicided as vig would be slightly indicative of X not having TMI on them being the vig because of how hard they’re hammering this point here but that’s probably a level -1 thought
6
X pondering over that for the entire game is both probably not W/W and is also independently wolfy
Z/X/Y all free pelts
7
mrrr this looks kinda bologna
i was gonna say “okay but she typoed so they were actually probably tired” but then i realized that the fact im going this far means that i am probably pocketed to some extent regardless of their alignment
8
im flip flopping a bit on X, but i’m leaning towards them being a villager because I think wolf!X would be a bit more scared of me. still think their thought process initially was weird, but that discussion is over
9
the fact nobody has directly commented to that post makes me think the thread is ~mostly villagers right now
its an easy post to reply to and pretend you’re contributing
10
X and Y probably both villagers, feel more strongly about the former but i generally find the excessive antagonistic posting, especially after being yelled at, to be village indicative
realistically Z is exactly rand and you can disregard the earlier read i made
11
i feel like X getting… a lot of flak for those posts
i can’t tell if it’s a natural amount
because i additionally don’t like the posts
i think the town:scum ratio is too towny for me to make a threadread like this though, so i don’t know why my brain is trying to do it
if it wasnt clear i agree with these posts
12
no its all in your wolfrange
so my theory is that you’re deliberately playing in your wolfrange
13
like im reading your ISO
and your reads are fluctuating more than the stock market did in 2008
14
im forcibly vetoing any towncore with X, Y, or Z in it
id be unsurprised if all 3 of them were non-town tbh
15
actually your last few messages feel like they’re leaning towards you not finishing reading so ill just ask this now
why are you a villager?
this is a boring question but like, i’m struggling to see it
now starring 15 posts
will grade your answers later
(some of these are slightly edited as to make it harder to identify the game via typing style/game identifying info)
