The Blackmailed Spy [Another ToL Merlin Attempt]

Class/Lore/Fanfic
#21

ToL only has one Gamemode.

#22

Doesn’t it have 2? Casual for private matches without Cult and other classes.

#23

Casual was removed.

#24

Oh I had no idea lol.

#25

Who’d be interested in a Mindnight misc?

#26

I genuinely can’t think of a more unfun class to play as. I’m sorry.

2 Likes
#27

Even if you got converted night one, you use your blackmail and they attempt to vote everyone.

#28

You’ve pitched this class as being a Merlin equivalent, but you’ve completely disregarded Merlin’s drawback. In The Resistance: Avalon, Merlin knows who all the evil players are, but the evils get a chance to guess who Merlin is at the end of the game, even if they lose. If they guess correctly, the evils win. If Merlin just outs who all the evils are, but then the evils just call out Merlin for being obvious Merlin, the good team still loses.

There is nothing stopping The Spy here from just outing who the evils are. The drawbacks you’ve listed here are by far not enough to compensate for perfect information on who the evil players are. If you dropped this class into Throne as it exists, all Spies would just say, protect/jail me, X is MM/CL and then the next day do the same thing to the new MM/CL when you vote the first one out. Evils have no counterplay and games would devolve to NK hunts very quickly.

This just doesn’t work.

5 Likes
#29

Where do I begin.

First off, this is a mafia game. People did not come here to play a different version of midnight. People came here for fun classes and conversion.

2 Likes
#30

An actual princsss can check you and notice you are social support and can’t be evil

#31

Or a sheriff

#32

lol