ToS Mafia - Day 8 - (3/19) [Town wins!]

…or unless Marshal is lying…

1 Like

Yeah but what can contradict that lie?

The fact that I didn’t kill Derps

And getting pranked would Marshal believe you did in fact visited SDA as Mafia.

It’s one of the three scenarios:

You did kill SDA and Marshal confirms as town.
Marshal framed you for murder
Marshal got pranked and saw you visiting SDA and mafia got rid of tracks of mafia killer.

Pretty sure someone said that prankster would fake results, but not interfere (so if a TI was told that they were roleblocked by trickster, they would still receive results anyways), so marshal couldn’t have been the victim of prankery

this

Yeah

They still can be victim by having “specific” players visiting the player and as I mentioned, hide the mafia killer so they can perform silent kills.

I asked Jgoes and he said that if a Prankster pranked me while I checked someone I would only get the pranked results not the real ones, I’m assuming it would be the same for Lookout

I’m not totally sure why the fake-roleblock interaction is different but

That is at least my take.

even if prankster could, say, give false results, marshal should have received two results

Oh, you do have a point there. But why would prankster be so lucky as to guess marshal to be lookout?

They are not roleblocked though, that is Eevee.

you will note that I am voting Marshal :upside_down_face:

We’re discussing the likelihood that prankster would perfectly guess marshal was lookout and give them incriminating results against arete

1 Like

No such thing as luck, but mafia have probably figured out either by reading the posts for softclaim.

i don’t think marshal ever softed

he softed TK :^)

Tinfoil: The fact that neither Arete nor Marshal care to back off each other indicates TvS/SvS and all other tinfoils putting them TvT are wrong.

Bold claim, I know folks.

marshal vs arete isn’t SvS

it’s just not possible